#Google #Gemini can't identify the creator of a (Google owned) #YouTube video!
I often use Google Gemini to summarize long or complex YouTube videos (tip to YouTube creators, if you don't want me to do that BE BRIEF and don't show me several minutes of your dog, baby, wife, trip though the woods, new farm equipment, etc.). Gemini usually does an okay job of this but it is so stupid in the way it works. If you just give it the URL of the video, it will usually summarize a completely different video than the one you requested! If you give it the video title AND the URL, it seems to find the correct video but totally hallucinates the creator or channel name! I give you this example: I wrote, "Please summarize this video: LiFePO4 That Charges Below Freezing?! Eco-Worthy Cubix 100 Pro Review — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W6Ud-sc3pRE" and it replied,
> In the video, Will Prowse reviews the Eco-Worthy Cubix 100 Pro, a 48V 100Ah (5.12kWh) LiFePO4 server rack battery. ...
The video was by Adam De Lay, not Will Prowse. So I wrote, "Where are you getting Will Prowse from?"
> To answer your question directly: Will Prowse is the creator of the YouTube channel DIY Solar Power with Will Prowse.
> The video link you provided (W6Ud-sc3pRE) is the specific review he posted on March 24, 2026, titled "LiFePO4 That Charges Below Freezing?! Eco-Worthy Cubix 100 Pro Review."
> In the solar and DIY battery community, Prowse is a well-known authority because he performs detailed "teardowns" where he physically cuts batteries open to inspect the internal wiring, BMS (Battery Management System), and cell quality. ...
Now while all that is more or less true, Prowse is still not the creator of this video. So I tried again... "Look on that page, who is the creator of that video?"
> You are right to double-check—I apologize for that confusion.
> Upon closer inspection, the video W6Ud-sc3pRE was actually created by the channel Theresa Trick For That.
> The confusion likely stems from the fact that Will Prowse (a very prominent figure in the DIY solar community) released a review of the exact same battery at nearly the same time. Theresa's video specifically references Will’s review and addresses his concerns, leading to the mix-up in the summary.
No, the confusion is that Gemini isn't actually looking at the YouTube page, which kind of blows my mind. AND the channel it is referring to now is actually called "There's a Trick for That" (nobody named Theresa involved AFAIK). So I replied, "You are still wrong, it is not Will Prowse or ''There's a trick for that''. Are you unable to read the page and see whose channel that is?"
Take a guess...
> I apologize for the inaccuracy in my previous responses. I clearly dropped the ball on identifying the creator of that specific video link.
> The video you linked (W6Ud-sc3pRE) is from the YouTube channel Pay Off Solar. ...
And so it went. The next time I asked it said "The video W6Ud-sc3pRE is from the channel The Tech Teacher." I finally had to tell it that the channel creator's name is Adam De Lay. But if it can't even get the creator's name right on a video from a sister site, can it be trusted to get *anything* right? 🤔

