my updated population map is now live at https://o.blanthorn.com/population-around-a-tile/map/#x=4.6481&y=50.5784&z=6.6381

compare cities with shift-click (or tick the accumulate button on mobile)

all running off a static file server so in theory it should still work in like ten years time

feedback much appreciated here or on the repo https://github.com/bovine3dom/population-around-a-tile/issues

@bovine3dom why is the maximum radius 990km not a nice round 1000km? I'm asking more for aesthetic rather than functional reasons

@wnd it's (rounded) multiples of https://h3geo.org/docs/core-library/restable/#edge-lengths

which are messy because they're hexagons and hexagons don't quite tile spherically, so they have to bodge it with a few pentagons (i think you know all this actually)

Tables of Cell Statistics Across Resolutions | H3

Cell counts

@bovine3dom @wnd crumbs, India looks busy. speaking of pentagons, would you consider also offering an a5 grid for "true" equal area comparisons? also, out of curiosity, how did you choose red for low and blue for high?

@joeldn hmm, A5 is sort of on my radar, but it only really matters if you forget to use the specific length/area for each cell. the downside of A5 is you lose the traversal

which in my defence, looking now, i have only done in two places (the distance from centre calculation and the cumulative population). i will fix those :)

if you go into the settings you can flip the scale. in my head it's like a flame, red is cold, yellow lukewarm, blue hot. but literally everyone disagrees with me

@wnd

@bovine3dom @joeldn there will be a variation in cell area whatever you do. There are 12 pentagons in the H3 projection, which is 10% at the coarsest resolution and becomes vanishing small at higher resolution:

https://h3geo.org/docs/core-library/restable/

For me, it is then how much you care. The Earth is an oblate spheroid with an approximate set of spherical coordinates based on EPSG:4326. Which is about 2m accuracy at the equator, less so elsewhere. YMMV

Tables of Cell Statistics Across Resolutions | H3

Cell counts

@wnd @joeldn

h3 vary much more than that, we're talking like max ~40% difference in edge length. the a5 site has a nice visualisation of it https://a5geo.org/examples/area

within a single country you don't need to care all that much but once you look across an entire continent it starts to bite

A5

@bovine3dom @joeldn maybe I need to reimplement my Full Automated European Luxury High Speed Railway using pentagons.

As I'm lazy and haven't read the manual, do you know whether these tiles have any rotational or translational symmetry?

@wnd @bovine3dom alas, it seems no rotational or translational symmetry - for route maps, flat top hex is nice for sensing main compass directions...is the map you mentioned available to look at at?

@joeldn this is a bit sketchy but there are a couple of examples here:

https://fosstodon.org/@wnd/115484726949074623

(There are bunch more of these at different scale which I should publish in a more structured way.

Also, if you are interested in such things here are some other things in my #Shed for the #30DayMapChallenge
https://anisotropi4.github.io/shed/30daymapchallenge.html)

@bovine3dom

@wnd @bovine3dom oh yes, I remember these now, especially the snowflake city effect!

@joeldn they're not...great...hence wanting to do something else here. Like the A5 projection. Unfortunately as these are very much a side hustle, work and life keep getting in the way.

@bovine3dom

@wnd @bovine3dom ah yes, when work/life balance becomes a work/life/culture juggle... making time for the latter isn't easy.