@tante @ai6yr I wrote about this yesterday, Mastodon's decision to voluntarily downsize in the face of AI. I think it's sad, but I'll take the clue and start unfollowing.
@buckfiftyseven @tante So let me get this right. You are an AI fan, and you don't like people who are not fans of AI (for the reasons in that post), so you are unfollowing people who don't like AI? That's fine, I guess. šŸ¤”

@ai6yr @tante

Honestly it was the "voluntary downsize" comment that got me.

Nobody wants to follow my hot takes and brilliant insights? Clearly, then, Mastodon must be what's pushing them away.

Dare Obasanjo (@[email protected])

Attached: 1 image Three month check-in on follower counts after posting the same content on all 3 apps • Threads (38K →40K): People love the shitposts and leave insightful comments on AI. • Bluesky (47K → 60K): People love the anti-Trump posts. • Mastodon (18K šŸ“‰): People hate AI and I’m steadily losing followers.

mas.to
@buckfiftyseven @jrconlin @tante Aww, poor AI influencer!

@ai6yr @jrconlin @tante here's the thing, what if he's not?

What if he's a mainstream technology observer, and what if Mastodon is in the process of divorcing themselves from the mainstream?

That's where I'm putting my bet for what it's worth.

@buckfiftyseven @ai6yr @tante

Or, what if, you know, AI isn't the mainstream that folk want to believe it is?

There are plenty of folk here that have strong following who are up-front about AI. (https://fedi.simonwillison.net/@simon comes to mind, but there are lots of others.) The thing is that the fediverse lives by recommendation. If folk aren't following what you're doing, it's because you're not finding your audience, where before someone else essentially did the marketing for you.

What cracks me up is that these folk are presuming that they are so special that folk would seek them out, and are surprised and whiny when that doesn't happen. If anything, I'd say that Mastodon reflects reality probably a fair bit more than the other platforms because you have to work to build your audience rather than have one farmed out to you.

(This probably also explains why Doritos doesn't set up stands at local farmers markets.)

Simon Willison (@[email protected])

9.26K Posts, 2.07K Following, 27.1K Followers Ā· Open source developer building tools to help journalists, archivists, librarians and others analyze, explore and publish their data. https://datasette.io and many other #projects.

Mastodon

@jrconlin @ai6yr @tante If Mastodon was in any kind of growth phase I think that might be a stronger argument.

But if the platform is shrinking at the same time as people are putting out purity requirements, maybe not.

The top post I replied to is obviously a purity test.

@buckfiftyseven @ai6yr @tante

I know, right? How will Mastodon ever be profitable and return positive value for it's shareholders.

( Sorry, I promise I'll stop laughing soon. )

@jrconlin @ai6yr @tante I understand that Mastodon is a public effort, and I have support it in a variety of ways. I've been doing patreon for 2-3 sites I didn't even use, even as I was hiring my own server separately.

But even if we think it's a public effort, do we want it to be a declining one? Perhaps only for right-thinking people?

@buckfiftyseven @ai6yr @tante

Yes. I would support this even if it was a declining effort. Because I would want to, and that's pretty much the same reason I would support any other effort. (there are a bunch of other "low value" projects I support, including a bunch of artists, musicians, programmers, and others. I'm weird that way. I like to make other folks happier.)

I'm not "investing" in the platform. I'm not looking for any down market reward. It's a goofy project that a bunch of folk find either fun or useful.