Balanced #DecisionMaking (single-blind #PeerReview) @ Plant Diversity
https://www.sciencedirect.com/journal/plant-diversity

Rev. 1: "... resolve the complex #reticulate evolutionary history of the Hoya-Dischidia lineage ... is ambitious and addresses an interesting evolutionary question, there are several fundamental flaws..."

Rev. 2: "... ambitious, the dataset is substantial, and the topic is suitable for Plant Diversity...a valuable piece of research with a strong methodological core."

Verdict: Reject