Winter Reruns: “As a female I wish I could wear Doc Martens to interviews”

I’m taking time off! I’ll be back with new content in February. Take this survey to share your opinions about what would be most helpful/interesting. While I’m out, I’m running a selection of Hiring Librarians’ greatest hits and most reviled posts.

This “What Should Candidates Wear?” survey response was completed on September 11, 2012 and ran on June 14, 2014. While this particular post may not be in the “most reviled posts” category, this survey certainly is (and rightly so). You can read more about some of the issues if you follow the links in the opening note on this post.

I regret having put this survey together, and running it for so long. I was attempting to help answer a common question, “What should I wear to my interview?” but ended up creating something that reinforced stereotypes and othering. When I wrote it, I identified as a feminist, but ultimately I had very little knowledge or understanding about gender as a construct, or gender theory beyond a few late 90s women’s studies courses. For example, I learned the word “cisgender” during the run of this survey, not before.

One of the purposes of Hiring Librarians is to illuminate the things that people who hire believe to be true, even when those opinions are pretty horrible. Hiring is an area where received wisdom, opinions, and bias can easily turn into policy and procedure. It’s important that we figure out what our unspoken beliefs are, so we can identify them as needing to change. This survey uncovered a lot of horrible beliefs, including my own. While there is at least that one positive, it doesn’t seem worth it. I apologize to the folks that this survey hurt.

So why run this now? I had a debate with myself, and have decided that unlike the other reruns, which I’ll post in full, I’m just going to link this one. It is high on the most views of all time list, which is what I’m trying to revisit during the break. With time as a buffer, the whole thing also feels a little less incendiary to me – it’s one of a lot of outdated ideas. Let me know if I’m wrong about that.

This post may be so popular because it was the last of this survey, but Google also tells me that one of the search queries that leads folks to the blog is “can you wear doc martens to an interview?” If that question lead you here I’ll give you my answer now: yes, you can wear Doc Martens to your interview. If that’s a deal breaker for your potential employer, maybe you don’t want to work there then.

Link to: As a female I wish I could wear Doc Martens to interviews

#interviewClothes #Librarian #libraries #libraryHiring #libraryInterview #libraryJobs