"The president who received five draft deferments—four for college, one for bad feet—continued to a room full of career officers....

For the next 70 minutes, he spoke slowly, slurring words, delivering to the hundreds of professionals who had rushed from around the world to attend this meeting a rambling, incoherent stream of words that jumped from what appeared to be prepared remarks to his own improvisation."

~ Heather Cox Richardson

#Trump #Hegseth #military
/1

https://heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/p/september-30-2025

September 30, 2025

Last Thursday, September 25, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth suddenly announced he was calling about 800 of the nation’s top military generals and admirals, along with their top enlisted advisors, to meet at Marine Corps Base Quantico, in Virginia, today.

Letters from an American

"The most remarkable aspect of Trump’s speech to the assembled generals and admirals of the US military was the silence.

The generals sat in silence.

They sat in silence as Trump slurred and rambled through a 'speech' that insulted the intelligence, professionalism, and loyalty of the generals."

~ Robert B. Hubbell

#Trump #Hegseth #military
/2

https://roberthubbell.substack.com/p/the-silence-of-the-generals

The silence of the generals.

October 1, 2025

Today's Edition Newsletter

"In their adolescent fantasies, Trump and Hegseth believed the generals would fête them with standing ovations, chanting, 'USA! USA! USA!'

Instead, Trump and Hegseth were humiliated as their unhinged, delusional words slapped sharply against the bare walls and fell to the ground, their lunacy heightened by the silence of the generals.

Without the crutch and cover of cheering crowds, Trump’s mental deterioration was laid bare for all to see."

#Trump #Hegseth #military #dementia
/3

"The true story of the speech is that it is also one of the most deranged speeches in the history of our nation.

That’s often what gets lost in all the coversge, where the media has to provide short, cogent snippets.

The truth is that generals and other top brass were hauled into a room from around the world to listen to 70 minutes of meandering, stream-of-conscious insanity."

~ David Pepper

#Trump #Hegseth #military #dementia
/4

https://davidpepper.substack.com/p/diagramming-a-historically-horrific

Diagramming a Historically Horrific Speech

Both Dangerous and Deranged

Pepperspectives

"If an aging narcissist is having more emotional outbursts, an even greater sense of entitlement, and loses the ability to hide their lack of empathy, these can be early warning signs that the narcissist has dementia too."

~ Sam Ray

#Trump #Hegseth #military #dementia
/5

https://samray.substack.com/p/malignant-narcissism-dementia

Malignant Narcissism + Dementia = ?

For absolutely no reason in particular, it seemed like a good time to gain greater clarity on how dementia normally impacts, affects, and changes the behavior of malignant narcissists, sociopaths, and psychopaths.

Counter-Narcissist Intelligence

"If they are a narcissist of the sadistic variety, they will almost certainly remain as cruel as ever, if not more so, so don’t hope for much, and know that it is them, not you. As with all forms of narcissists, dementia will exacerbate their feelings of anxiety, paranoia, and suspiciousness, which will increase their desire to exert more power and control, and their default for that is cruelty."

#Trump #Hegseth #military #dementia
/6

"The generals and admirals should be forgiven if they walked out of the auditorium and wondered: What on earth is wrong with the commander in chief? ...

In 1973, an Air Force nuclear-missile officer named Harold Hering asked a simple question during a training session: 'How can I know that an order I receive to launch my missiles came from a sane president?' The question cost him his career."

~ Tom Nicholls

#Trump #Hegseth #military #dementia
/7

https://www.theatlantic.com/newsletters/archive/2025/09/trump-hegseth-speech-incoherent/684421/?gift=63Gh33MHIm6zIngFjhtdLQM1zNpGlrmE-JRFV3ScPho&utm_source=copy-link&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=share

The Commander in Chief Is Not Okay

Trump put on a disturbing show for America’s generals and admirals.

The Atlantic

"Military members are trained to execute orders, not question them. But today, both the man who can order the use of nuclear arms and the man who would likely verify such an order gave disgraceful and unnerving performances in Quantico. How many officers left the room asking themselves Major Hering’s question?"

#Trump #Hegseth #military #dementia
/8

"Today, our military leaders personified the ethos the former Secretaries of Defense called for in their pre-January 6 letter, which we reviewed in last night’s post. The military isn’t about Hegseth’s phony warrior ethos, which would exclude many people who have served bravely from the military."

~ Joyce Vance

#Trump #Hegseth #military #dementia
/9

https://joycevance.substack.com/p/the-first-amendment-and-a-court-punch

The First Amendment (And A Court) Punch Back

Tonight, we have a post that is longer than usual.

Civil Discourse with Joyce Vance

"The generals and admirals sat mostly stone-faced as Trump delivered an inappropriate partisan speech. They did their duty by being there, but nothing more."

#Trump #Hegseth #military #dementia
/10

"America’s toxic masculinity crisis was on full display today when Pete Hegseth, Secretary of Defense or, as he likes to say, Secretary of War, stood up in front of a room full of generals, admirals, and other senior military brass and lectured them about what it meant to be a real man."

~ Mary Trump

#Trump #Hegseth #military #dementia #ToxicMasculinity #overcompensation #MachoCosplaying
/11

https://www.marytrump.org/p/mary-trump-live-2e3

Mary Trump Live

30 September, 2025

The Good in Us by Mary L. Trump

"There was no hooting, no hollering, no one applauded. They just sat like this. Like, it was emasculating in a way that this man who desperately tries to cosplay as an alpha was seen as a beta cuck by U.S. military leaders. Like, that was, I thought literally, and them televising this, I think it was even worse."

~ Wajahat Ali

#Trump #Hegseth #military #dementia #ToxicMasculinity #overcompensation #MachoCosplaying
/12

https://thelefthook.substack.com/p/shutting-down-a-fascist-regime-run

Shutting Down a Fascist Regime Run By Weak, Incompetent Bullies

A government shutdown, a cankled Trump, a manic Hegseth, a splintering MAGA base, a declining economy, the looming Epstein Files, and an opportunity for Democrats to finally lead.

The Left Hook with Wajahat Ali

"Trump laid out a lawless, authoritarian vision for the armed forces, including fighting a 'war from within' against the his domestic enemies.

In other words, boots on the ground — in places like Portland, not Pyongyang."

~ Justin Glawe

#Trump #Hegseth #military #dementia
/13

https://www.publicnotice.co/p/trump-military-speech-posse-comitatus

Trump attempts a major step toward dictatorship

He's going for it. Who will stop him?

Public Notice

"The phrase 'enemy from within' has an ugly history. It was famously used by Senator Joseph McCarthy in a 1950 speech: 'When a great democracy is destroyed, it will not be from enemies from without, but rather because of enemies from within.' (McCarthy attributed the quote to 'one of our outstanding historical figures,' but that claim appears to be apocryphal.)"

~ Judd Legum, Rebecca Crosby, and Noel Sims

#Trump #Hegseth #military #dementia
/14

https://popular.info/p/trump-declares-war-on-america

Trump declares war on America

"It’s the enemy from within and we have to handle it before it gets out of control."

Popular Information

"McCarthy used the concept of the 'enemy within' to justify the trampling of civil rights and academic freedom. Earlier, the Ottoman Empire used the concept of the 'enemy within' to rationalize the Armenian genocide."

#Trump #Hegseth #military #dementia
/15

Entitling his commentary "Bulging Biceps Don’t Win Modern Wars," Paul Krugman writes,

"Hegseth’s speech was morally vile. It was also, however, profoundly stupid. Hegseth seems to have gotten his ideas about what an effective military looks like by watching the movie 300."

#Trump #Hegseth #military #ToxicMasculinity #misogyny #racism #DEI #woke #stupidity
/16

https://paulkrugman.substack.com/p/bulging-biceps-dont-win-modern-wars

Bulging Biceps Don’t Win Modern Wars

Hegseth’s speech was vile. It was also stupid.

Paul Krugman

"A military rife with sexual abuse and bigotry isn’t going to attract the best minds — many of which, although people like Hegseth will never believe it, reside in female and nonwhite bodies.

…All of this is of a piece with Trumpian policy in other domains."

#Trump #Hegseth #military #ToxicMasculinity #misogyny #racism #DEI #woke #stupidity
/17

"Of course a regime that believes it can make America great by defunding science and destroying higher education believes that it can make our military more effective by making it prejudiced and stupid.

The good news is that America’s officer corps isn’t stupid, at least not yet."

#Trump #Hegseth #military #ToxicMasculinity #misogyny #racism #DEI #woke
/18

"The stony silence with which the assembled generals and admirals greeted Hegseth’s and Trump’s rants was eloquent.

But you can now add the military to the list of great American institutions that MAGA is, in effect, trying to destroy."

#Trump #Hegseth #military #ToxicMasculinity #misogyny #racism #DEI #woke #stupidity
/19

"The other thing that he said was, as history teaches us, the only people who actually deserve peace are those who are willing to wage war to defend it. That's why pacifism is naive and dangerous."

~ Allison Gill

#Trump #Hegseth #military #fascism
/20

https://thelefthook.substack.com/p/magas-animal-house-military-frat

MAGA's Animal House Military Frat For Insecure Men

Pete Hegseth and Donald Trump attempt to hide their weak, fragile egos and numerous shortcomings through a dangerous military cosplay.

The Left Hook with Wajahat Ali

"And Aaron Reichland Melnick pointed out, war is peace is one of the three core slogans of the fascist government in the book 1984. And it's damn chilling to see the Secretary of Defense demanding that the U.S. Armed Forces adopt it as truth."

#Trump #Hegseth #military #fascism
/21

"Michael Wolff: Is it dementia or something else? What one of Donald Trump's closest political advisors revealed to me."

#Trump #Hegseth #military #stupidity
/22

https://bsky.app/profile/iwillnotbesilenced.bsky.social/post/3lzmech76hk2p

Raider (@iwillnotbesilenced.bsky.social)

Michael Wolff: Is it dementia or something else? What one of Donald Trump's closest political advisors revealed to me.

Bluesky Social

"Trump and Hegseth did serve important national interests on Tuesday. It’s just that the nation whose interests they served wasn’t ours. The spectators in the Kremlin must have laughed when they heard Hegseth mock 'diversity' and proclaim that 'unity is our strength.'

Trump and Hegseth clearly hate diversity. But they wouldn’t know unity if it bit them in the ass."

~ Will Saletan

#Trump #Hegseth #military #stupidity
/23

https://www.thebulwark.com/p/the-silence-of-the-generals-hegseth-trump-quantico-speech-william-young-ice-opinion

The Silence of the Generals

And the searing words of a veteran on the bench.

The Bulwark

As Evan Hurst reports, from late-night comedians like Jimmy Kimmel to Stephen Colbert and Military Reddits, Trump-Hegseth are being resoundingly mocked now. Hurst offers links and video clips — including to MSNBC's Pentagon reporter Helene Cooper reporting on what she's hearing said inside the military.

#Trump #Hegseth #military #stupidity
/24

https://www.wonkette.com/p/here-are-your-clips-of-late-night

Here Are Your Clips Of Late Night Audiences Laughing At Loser Pete Hegseth

F-A-F-O what happens when you're such a fucking dork.

Wonkette

And, of course, cartoonists are adding to the commentary, including Nick Anderson, whose "Men, let me tell you about the warrior ethos" cartoon is featured by by Gene Weingarten.

#Trump #Hegseth #military #ToxicMasculinity #overcompensation #MachoCosplaying
/25

https://geneweingarten.substack.com/p/loud-and-clear-sir

"Trump has checked off the list of independent sources of political power that authoritarians typically target: the courts, law enforcement, the press, universities, and civil society organizations, among others. The military remains a key holdout. But none of these institutions can resist alone, and even together they can’t resist forever without broad-based cultural support for them."

~ David Kurtz

#Trump #Hegseth #military #fascism
/26

https://morningmemo.talkingpointsmemo.com/p/the-test-of-our-time-even-the-military

The Test of Our Time: Even the Military Can’t Resist Trump on Its Own Forever

INSIDE: Pete Hegseth ... Sigal Chattah ... E.J. Antoni

Morning Memo

"While silence was the only reaction that the assembled brass on Tuesday could and should have displayed, there is no such bar for retired military leaders.

Many did not hold back.

Retired Commander of U.S. Army Europe Lt. Gen. Mark Hertling called the remarks 'shocking' and 'offensive.'

Ret. Major General William Enyart described Trump’s use of the words 'enemy from within' as 'Hitleresque' and 'right out of Nazi Germany.'”

~ Jay Kuo

#Trump #Hegseth #military
/27

https://statuskuo.substack.com/p/a-funny-thing-happened-on-the-way

A Funny Thing Happened On the Way to the Fascism

Silence is golden, and so was the generals’ reaction to Hegseth and Trump.

The Status Kuo

"Retired U.S. Marine Colonel Mark Cancian, in an interview with NPR, called the possibility of an order authorizing the use of lethal force in U.S. cities a 'huge problem,' explaining that the military is not trained on when the use of such force is appropriate against civilians."

#Trump #Hegseth #military #fascism
/28

"Retired Gen. Barry McCaffrey called the gathering 'one of the strangest, most incoherent national security events' he has ever encountered, describing it as 'a bitter partisan sort-of "savage tone" address.' He described the idea that the military would train to operate within U.S. cities 'deeply unsettling.'”

#Trump #Hegseth #military #fascism
/29

Commenting on the Trump-Hegseth performance yesterday, Kristin Du Mez points to a passage in her book Jesus and John Wayne in which she discussewd retired colonel David Antoon's commentary on the infusion of warrior rhetoric in the military in the 2000s.

She wrote,

"Antoon identified a source of this inflitration."

#Trump #Hegseth #military #fascism #evangelicals #WhiteChristianNationalism #WarriorEthos
/30

https://kristindumez.substack.com/p/catching-up

Catching Up

What I've done, where I'll be

Du Mez CONNECTIONS

"He’d seen cadets and families at the Cadet Chapel welcomed by 'a phalanx of enthusiastic pastors' and recruited to Monday night Bible studies taught by members of New Life Church and Focus on the Family staff bused in for that purpose. The academy, Antoon realized, had become 'a giant Trojan horse for evangelicals to get inside the military.'”

#Trump #Hegseth #military #fascism #evangelicals #WhiteChristianNationalism #WarriorEthos
/31

"What the Trump Administration faced this morning was two words: COLD REJECTION. Rejection of the Trump Administration to lead the Commanders of the United States Military into the future of 21st Century warfare."

~ Terrence Goggin

#Trump #Hegseth #military #fascism
/32

https://thewestpointhistoryprofessor.substack.com/p/the-us-militarys-silent-fury-a-trump

THE U.S. MILITARY’S SILENT FURY: A TRUMP-HEGSETH DISASTROUS EVENT

A SPECIAL REPORT

The West Point History Professor
@wdlindsy "Gott mit uns" has always been a thing. Not a good one as we know now.

@wdlindsy I can save him some time trying to figure out when it's appropriate to use the military against civilians.

It's never appropriate. Ever. Under any circumstances.

@wdlindsy

by coincidence, did you see the BBC story about the Bloody Sunday Massacre trial

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c80gxzpvzl3o

Bloody Sunday: Soldier F trial told victim pretended he was dead

Soldier F denies murdering James Wray, 22, and William McKinney, 26, as well as five counts of attempted murder.

BBC News
@wdlindsy the members of the military have pledged their lives and blood to protect the people of the United States

@wdlindsy

"Then there was the woman officer they spoke to, who had this to say, among other things, about Hegseth’s speech and its weird focus on PT and shaving:
“It’s something I would expect from a captain or a. major,” the officer said. “I don’t want the secretary of. war to be focused on baseline PT stuff.”

Great illumination of the fact that Hegseth is utterly unqualified for the job - does not even know, this far along, what his job is.

#Hegseth
#Wonkette

@wdlindsy

Found while following the link in Wonkette's post, to responses in a military reddit thread: yes, Hegseth, so presumably Trump, did know that the oath concern was out there:

@Edelruth Thanks for noting this and for the link.

@wdlindsy

Military reddit being mean it: "could have been an email, a boner pill email"

@wdlindsy Hegseth is virtue signaling. Putting all the top commanders in one place is a serious and unnecessary risk and waste of resources. A real professional would have sent an email
@mdziemann @wdlindsy
They only know how to use markers.
@wdlindsy
they confuse "unity" and "uniformity" ^^
@wdlindsy An excellent read. Every American should take this to heart. BABA (BUY ANYTHING BUT AMERICAN)
@wdlindsy I find that an absolutely shocking read. God help America (by which I mean the US) and God help the rest of the world.
@wdlindsy
There are things I'd not have said to one General, never mind 300.
The politicians may have driven unity.

@wdlindsy

"He [Trump] really *is* an idiot."
- Sam Nunberg

@wdlindsy @rgulick Right, he is n idiot! That was obvious even before the election...

@thierry_van_kerm @wdlindsy

Only obvious to people who aren't idiots, apparently.

@rgulick @wdlindsy that make a lot of idiots! 😂
@wdlindsy I'm surprised to read about the Armenian Genocide in the context of Trumps speech, because it was Hitler asking his generals a week before WW2: "Who, after all, speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians?" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hitler%27s_Obersalzberg_Speech
The vibe, the attitude is the same, showing lawlessness is key, wanting to pledge the generals to illegal and in the end genocidal conduct.
Hitler's Obersalzberg Speech - Wikipedia

@wdlindsy

Well, justnow the American Democracy indeed has a big problem of enemy from within...

From within the While House and the Pentagon, in fact, where it is most dangerous 🤔

@wdlindsy

in fact, listening some recent speaches looked like *living* Braindead next season 🧠