#GiftArticle

What the Public Memory of #CharlieKirk Revealed

For those who felt denigrated by his rhetoric, the bipartisan tributes to him as a champion of free speech augured something dangerous: the #mainstreaming of formerly #extremist views.

By Nikole Hannah-Jones

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/28/magazine/charlie-kirk-rhetoric.html?unlocked_article_code=1.pU8.xYGk.f_VTKCpgv7OH&smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare

What the Public Memory of Charlie Kirk Revealed

For those who felt denigrated by his rhetoric, the bipartisan tributes to him as a champion of free speech augured something dangerous: the mainstreaming of formerly extremist views.

The New York Times
The day #CharlieKirk was killed, Dominic Durant’s 11yo daughter came home from her middle school in Tulsa, OK, & told her father that her friends had been very upset about his death, & that they felt she should be upset, too. “I’m sad,” she said, tears in her eyes.
Durant struggled with how to respond. He, too, had been appalled by the act of violence. But his young daughter did not know much about #Kirk, & he worried she would look him up on YouTube & come across the many ugly assertions the right-wing activist had made about #Black Americans like them.
For instance, Kirk had claimed that 4 prominent & successful #BlackWomen, who all went to Ivy League universities — Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, the fmr first lady Michelle Obama, the TV host Joy-Ann Reid & fmr Rep Sheila Jackson Lee of Texas — did not “have the brain processing power to otherwise be taken really seriously” & had to “go steal a white person’s slot.” He’d argued that “Black America is poorer, more murderous, more dangerous” than when #Black people were living under #JimCrow.

Durant did not want his daughter thinking that because her friends were grieving him that the things #Kirk had claimed were acceptable or right.

It was a difficult & heart-rending conversation, grappling with how his daughter’s classmates could admire a man who’d said such hurtful things. “I said it’s natural to be sad & I don’t want to change your opinion about being sad,” Durant recounted.

Durant continued, “But I am explaining to you that the gentleman who just got shot was under the impression that you, as a young #Black #woman, don’t have brain processing power. So I am explaining it to you to let you know what he said was wrong & not true.”

As a Christian, Durant also felt he had to address #Kirk’s version of #Christianity, which condemned & disparaged people who are #gay & #transgender.

#Kirk once posted, “The pride & trans movements have always been about grooming kids.” In another instance, he had pointed to a passage in the Bible that said men who lay with other men “shall be stoned to death,” saying it “affirms God’s perfect law when it comes to sexual matters.”

This #intolerance was not reflective of Durant’s own understanding of Jesus or the Gospel, nor the faith his family practiced. “I reminded her not to be a hypocritical Christian,” he said.

“I told her, You know, the Good Book, the Bible, says you judge a man as he lived, not as he died.”

Durant left the conversation about Kirk’s death grateful that it had prompted a father-daughter talk about his child’s #worth as a #Black #girl & about having empathy for those marginalized by society. He hoped that this moment of beatifying #Kirk had passed.

But a few days later, #Oklahoma’s superintendent of #schools, #RyanWalters, directed all the state’s schools to observe a moment of silence in honor of #Kirk. Durant felt a shock that quickly flamed into outrage.

People were free to mourn Kirk or not, he said, but the #state had no right to #order his #child & other #children to honor a man whose words had often denigrated them. “My initial thought was, Hell no — there’s no way.”

He’d already decided that his daughter would not participate when, to his relief, the #Tulsa #PublicSchools, a district that is majority #Black & #Latino, & several other #Oklahoma #school districts announced that they would not comply with the dictate. For that, they now face a state #investigation for failing to commemorate the activist who Walters said was a champion of free speech, civil debate & conservative & Christian values.
#Oklahoma, of course, is a deeply red state. But in the wake of Kirk’s death, individuals & institutions across the nation moved not just to condemn his killing & political violence, but to venerate him. It was unsettling to many to see politicians from across the political spectrum speak with reverence about a man who espoused the #racist #GreatReplacementTheory, which argues that #white Americans are being systematically replaced by #multiculturalism & by #brown & #Black #immigrants;
who continuously claimed that “there’s a war on #white people in this country; who said it was “a fact” that “prowling Blacks go around for fun to go target white people”; who gave a platform to people who believe in #eugenics & race *science*; who contended that #Black people commit more crime than white people & that the blame lies in a Black culture that accepts that Black men “impregnate women & they don’t stay around”;
who referred to a #transgender athlete as an “abomination” & called “the transgender thing” a “throbbing middle finger to God”; & who declared that #Islam, the world’s second-largest #religion, “is not compatible with Western civilization” & that it is a sword being used “to slit the throat of America.”
Still, #NFL & #MLB teams held moments of silence. #CSPAN covered Kirk’s memorial service live. #Cardinal #TimothyDolan recounted how, after Kirk’s death, he spent time researching & determined that #Kirk was a “modern day St. Paul” & a “hero” albeit “pretty blunt” & “pretty direct.” Mainstream news outlets such as #CNN & #CBS invited #JackPosobiec to come speak about his friend’s “life’s work,” & about how to “fill this void” Kirk had left behind.

These outlets did not mention that Posobiec is a #ConspiracyTheorist who has been labeled an #extremist by the #SouthernPovertyLawCenter because of his ties to #WhiteSupremacists & #neoNazis.

Even #Democratic politicians felt compelled to pay tribute. Gov #JoshShapiro of #Pennsylvania ordered flags to be flown at half-staff “as a mark of respect for the memory of #CharlieKirk,” though he later criticized Kirk’s rhetoric.

Gov #GavinNewsom of #California, who has crafted an image of himself as the face of the #MAGA #resistance, implored that “the best way to honor Charlie’s memory is to continue his work.” And last week, the House passed a bipartisan measure to honor #Kirk, with 95 #Democrats joining #Republicans to vote for a resolution in support of the man who said that President Joseph R. #Biden Jr. “should be put in prison and/or given the death penalty for his crimes against America.”
@Nonilex
Yes, that's #opportunistic #GavinNewsom, at work. And that #Democrats think he might be a good Presidential candidate? #sheesh