Claudius LinkMar 3

If you ever asked yourself what the difference and overlap of ICS Security and Cybersecurity of Medical devices, here is a "helpful" AI generated Venn diagram showing it /s
🤪

Generate by Copilot with roughly the prompt
"Create a Venn diagram depicting the relation of ICS Security and the security of medical devices"

#AiFail #MedicalDeviceSecurity #IcsSecurity #Cybersecurity

Show threadClaudius LinkMar 3

I tried it again after resetting the context (and after some time)

At least this time I got Venn diagrams
(I extended the prompt to contain OT, ICS, SCADA and Medical Devices)

And just told Copilot that it was wrong

#AIFail

Show threadClaudius LinkMar 3
As a reference what I would have expected (leaving out the Medical Device part)
Show threadClaudius Link

I also tried OpenAI #DeepResearch

The textual description was promising

  • OT (Operational Technology) is the broadest category, encompassing all industrial control systems.
  • ICS (Industrial Control Systems) is a subset of OT, including SCADA, DCS, and PLCs.
  • SCADA (Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition) is a subset of ICS, specifically for remote monitoring and control.
  • Medical Devices overlap with OT but have unique characteristics, such as patient safety and healthcare regulations.

It is interesting that PLC and DCS are mentioned without being part of my prompt.

But the Venn diagram was again a total failure

Mar 3 at 1:20pmWeb