An update on our Terms of Use | The Mozilla Blog

On Wednesday we shared that we’re introducing a new Terms of Use (TOU) and Privacy Notice for Firefox. Since then, we’ve been listening to some of our

@plwt This doesn't give much more clarity. It doesn't add back in the text they removed.

"there are a number of places where we collect and share some data with our partners"

This is incredibly vague.

@plwt >TL;DR Mozilla doesn’t sell data about you (in the way that most people think about “selling data”), and we don’t buy data about you. We changed our language because some jurisdictions define “sell” more broadly than most people would usually understand that word. Firefox has built-in privacy and security features, plus options that let you fine-tune your data settings.

False. That is exactly how most people think of "selling data."

@plwt still utterly fails to explain what data they need a license for or why they need a license. It's obviously vague on purpose because they intend to abuse it.
@plwt I'd love to know what they think the average punter thinks the verb "to sell" means, because the definition they decry as being overly broad is exactly what I think "sell your personal data" means.
@plwt
Thanks for sharing. I’ll stick with #Kagi’s Orion, which is in beta.

@plwt I don't understand how they thought that these clarifications about purpose weren't going to be absolutely necessary in the first instance.

It still feels unfortunate to just delete the promise about not selling data. They must have explicitly chosen not to instead change the wording and articulate (rightly or wrongly) that they are adapting to a changing legal landscape regarding wording, rather than changing their intent.

@plwt @jer lawyers. They ruin everything. We can’t even agree on a plain English word like “sale” anymore apparently. Da heck?

@plwt even if this blog posts rectified anything.....
It should have been obvious from the get-go that these changes would have caused community controversy.
If these changes were read by anyone at Firefox, they would have known that it would be scrutinized.

Either mozilla thinks we're too stupid to have noticed these things.
Or mozilla's too stupid to imagine this wouldn't have caused any issues

@plwt I can't believe they think the screencapped text excuses them. The quote is not some incomprehensible legalese, it is absolutely on point about selling the data through various means.

@plwt
> TL;DR Mozilla doesn’t sell data about you (in the way that most people think about “selling data”),

hahahahahaha no.

@plwt @drakulix "[…] In order to make Firefox commercially viable, there are a number of places where we collect and share some data with our partners, including our optional ads on New Tab and providing sponsored suggestions in the search bar…" - Firefox, or the Mozilla Foundation, was never meant to be "financially viable" as in "business", but women assholes (aka CEOs) decided that that wasn't good enough.

Fuck them!