Arcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

OK, let's do this and see if I can get finished before #GURPS starts.

Pretty much the same as the last thread, only focusing on my main (whale-ish) account #arcadia instead of my Cheap to play #marika. #FGO

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

Mostly the same rules as before:

So, ground rules for this. #FGO
A new 5⭐ that's a priority target - 20
A new 5⭐ that's not a priority - 10
A 5⭐ that #marika already has but would like additional copy(s) of - 10
A 5⭐ that woulb be OK to get additional copies of - 5
A 5⭐ that is already at NP5, i.e. a USO (Unregistered Spirit Origin) - -10.

Ashiya Douman, the ultimate #arsehat of #FGO is a FLAT NO. #arcadia

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

Ok, so #Saber1 #FGO #arcadia

Arthur - 10 (new but not great)
Okita Souji - 10 (despite being NP3 already)
Sigurd - 10 (Currently Np1)
Umu Bride - 10 (Currently NP2
Musashi - 10 (Currently NP2)
Shiki - 10 (currently NP2)

Score: 60/10 Not brilliant. 1/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Saber2 #FGO #arcadia
Astolfo -10 (NP1)
Ibuki Douji - 20
Okita Alter - 10 (NP1)
Charlemagne - 10 (Np1)
Senji Muramasa - 5 (NP3)
Hai Ba Trung - 10 (Currently NP2)
Beni Enma - 20

85/12. Better (somewhat), but not much. 2/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Archer1 #FGO #Arcadia - This is one of THE star banners for #Marika

Squirtoria - -10 (NP5, so that would be a USO 😭 )
Ishtar - 10 (NP1)
Gilgamesh - 10 (NP1)
Moriarty - 10 (NP1, turns out I do have him)

20/5. Very much a hard pass I think. 3/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Archer2 #FGO #arcadia

Jeanne Archer - 10 (NP3)
Sei Shounagon - 10 (new, but...)
Super Orion - 5 (Already NP2, and that's fine)

25/8 1/3. At this rate the Sabers are actually starting to look viable... 4/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#lancer1 #FGO #arcadia
Ereshkigal - 10 (Currently NP1)
Scathach - 10 (Currently NP1)
Tamamo no Mae - 10 (NP1)
Brynhildr - 10

40/10 with only one new unit, and not one that I'm overly keen on getting anyway. 5/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Lancer2 #FGO #arcadia

Ryouma Sakamoto - 10 (NP2)
Melusine -10 (which given that I already have NP4 is actually easy to stick to my rules. Yes #MelusineIsBroken but Np5 is probably overdoing it)
Romulus Quirinus - 20

40/13 1/3 A relatively strong showing. 6/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Rider1 #FGO #arcadia OK, out of the Knights and into the cavalry
Altria Alter (Maid Alter) - 10 (NP2)
Ivan the Terrible - 20
Iskandar - 10

STILL Not terribly enthused by this set. 40 / 13 1/3 Score is looking decent though. 7/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

##Rider2 #FGO #arcadia
Kyokutei Bakin - 10 (NP1)
Konstaninos - 10 (EWWW)
Reines - 10 (NP4)
Da Vinci Lily - 10 (NP2, more would be nice)

Admittedly Konstantinos got a REALLY nice buff on JP recently...but that's two years away and makes him a booby prize

40/10 and out of the running.

8/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Caster1 #FGO Casters are definitely one of #arcadia's stronger classes and may not need bolstering

Ilya - 10 (Currently Np3)
Skadi - 10 (Currently NP4)
Summer Nero - 20
Merlin - 10 (Currently NP2)
Da Vinci - 10 (Currently NP1)

Much reinforcement, little development. 60/12. 9/20

Show threadArcadiagt5

#Caster2 #FGO #arcadia

Castoria - -10 (NP5 😭)
Izumo no Okuni - 10 (NP1)
Miss Crane - 20
Murasaki Shikibu - 10 (Currently Np1)

30/7.5 Only one new unit (admittedly Miss Crane WOULD be a nice get) with a risk of a USO. 10/20

Jun 28, 2024 at 10:03amWeb
Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Assassin1 #FGO #arcadia
Cleopatra - 10 (nice unit, talk to me when they fix Imperial Privilege)
Shuten Douji -10 (NP1)
MHX - 10 (currently NP2)
King Hassan - 20 (would be good to get)

50/12.5 Not brilliant. 11/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Assassin2 #FGO #arcadia
Kama - 10 (NP3)
Semiramis - 10 (I liked her in #FateApocrypha but...)
Koyanskaya - 10 (Currently NP2)

30/10 Not great given what I already have. 12/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Berserker1 #FGO #arcadia

Sakata Kintoki - GOLDEN! - 10 (NP1)
MHXA - 20
Hijikata Toshizo - 10
Minamoto no Raiko - 10 (not a fan of the #EscherGirls character design).

50/12.5 I am admittedly missing 3 of the 4 but two of those I'm kind of "meh" on. 13/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Berserker2 #FGO #arcadia
Arjuna Alter - -10 (NP5, i.e. 😭 )
Musashi - 10 (Currently NP1)
Morgan le Fay - -10 (NP5, i.e 😭 )

-10/ -3 1/3. An actual negative score! PASS... 14/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Extra1 #RulerAvenger #FGO #arcadia
Amakusa Shirou - 20
Sherlock Holmes - 10 (NP1)
Edmond Dantes - 10 (NP1)
JALTER - 10 (NP3)

50/12.5 with one new unit in 4. 15/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Extra2 Rulers, Avengers, and a MoonCancer #FGO #arcadia

Bunny Artoria - 10 (NP1)
Qin Shi Huang - 20
Spishtar - 10 (Currently NP2)
Maou Nobu - 10 (NP2)
Summer BB - 10 (NP3)

60/12 OKish... I guess. 16/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Extra3 Still more Rulers, Avengers and Moon Cancers
Caren - 10 (Currently NP1)
Moriarty - 20
Himiko - -10 (NP5 so 😭)
Summer Kama - 10 (NP2)
Taira no Kagekiyo - 10 (Currently NP1)
Sessyoin Kiara - 20

#FGO #arcadia
60/10 but with a risk of a USO. 17/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Extra4 Alter Egos and Foreigners #FGO #arcadia
Okita Souji Alter - 10 (NP1)
Sessyoin Kiara - 10 (NP1)
Meltryllis - 10 (NP3)
Abagail Williams - 10 (NP1)
Katsushika Hokusai - 10 (NP1)

50/10 Not brilliant. 18/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Extra5 Alter Egos and Foreigners again
King Protea -10 (NP2)
Summer Abagail WIlliams - 10
Van Gogh - 10 (NP1)
Voyager - 20
Yang Guifei - 10 (NP2)

60/12 It's probably one of the better scores but... meh. #FGO #arcadia 19/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#Extra6 Alter Egos, Foreigners, and Pretenders
Ashiya Douman - -20 (I legitimately DO NOT WANT. I despise this arsehat and don't want him anywhere near my Chaldea (despite how good his gameplay is)
Super Bunyan - 10 (NP1)
Mananann Mac Lir - 10 (NP1)
Jacques de Molay - 10 (NP2)
Koyan Dark - 10 (Currently NP3)
Oberon - 10 (Currently NP1)

30/6 No, just no, Not when there's a risk of THAT arsehat turning up. #FGO #marika 20/20

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024
#FGO #arcadia Final Scores given as Total/Average
1. #Saber1 - 60/10
2. #Saber2 - 85/12
3. #Archer1 - 20/5
4. #Archer2 - 25/8 1/3
5. #Lancer1 40/10
6. #Lancer2 40/13 1/3
7. #Rider1 40/13 1/3
8. #Rider2 40/10 (but ewww Konstaninos)
9 #Caster1 - 60/12
10. #Caster2 - 30/7.5
11. #Assassin1 50/12/5
12. #Assassin2 30/10
13. #Berserker1 50/12.5
14. #Berserker2 -10/ -3 1/3 (!)
Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024

#FGO #arcadia Final scores continued
15. #Extra1 50/12.5 *
16. #Extra2 60/12
17. #Extra3 60/10
18. #Extra4 50/10
19. #Extra5 60/12
20 #Extra6 30/6 (and a HELL NO for Douman)

It's marginal but #Lancer2 or #Rider1? Not terribly enthused by any of these to be honest.

Show threadArcadiagt5Jun 28, 2024
Nothing averaging above 13 1/3 for #arcadia where #marika has 2 banners at 20 (representing all new units that would be good to have). This really shows the difference in depth between the two accounts… #FGO