I have finished reading God Emperor of Dune. It ended exactly as it must, but I’m still not certain what to think of it. So far it’s my least favorite book, mostly because of the homophobia.

My recommendation is to probably stop at book 2 or 3.

But I shall forge ahead anyway.

#Reading #SciFi #Dune #GodEmperorOfDune

Okay, I’m not yet certain it is worth it, but it feels like you can absolutely skip God Emperor of Dune and make sense of Heretics. You just have to know it’s thousands of years after Children, and it’s a new era.

And for some reason everyone is still obsessed with Jason Momoa.

PS: Improve your copies of Dune by crossing off Duncan Idaho and writing in Jason Momoa.

PPS I love how you can do that for lady Jessica and nothing changes.

#Reading #SciFi #Dune #HereticsOfDune

@deinol I really dislike the DUNC casting of giant dude Momoa as slightly-above-average Human reference stick Duncan Idaho. Lynch's casting of second-banana from Logan's Run was perfect.

That's an important part of God-Emperor as Duncan falls further and further behind mainstream Humans, he's like a pet for the Fish Speakers by the end.
#dune

@deinol Messiah, Children and God Emperor were my least favourite. Heretics and Chapterhouse are very different books, but re-ignited my flame. Given the time-lapsed, it worked for me. I know many disagree. I do appreciate God Emperor for the gaming possibilities compared to the others.

I love Jason Momoa, but he is miscast. Every screen Duncan has been. Viewing the #Dune universe told through the eyes of Duncan is the gamer gold. Make all the PCS gholas and kill them regularly with impunity.

@deinol Agreed. It is unfortunate that after the third book everything just goes downhill...
@deinol I've only read 1-3 and am about to start God-Emperor, so thanks for the warning.
@deinol It only gets worse from here on. This is why it is difficult for me to get excited about the new movies. So much waste, they could make Use of Weapons by Banks instead.

@deinol things only go down from God Emperor (and as you noticed God Emperor is already pretty low on the ground)

https://fosstodon.org/@gabrielesvelto/110980738225196476

Gabriele Svelto (@[email protected])

Attached: 1 image If you picked an interest in #Dune thanks to the new movie, know that you might also run into the many, many books written by Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson. They're not particularly good. However, if you go past Dune and want to read the rest of the books written by Frank Herbert, be aware that they're not exactly great either. There's valid reasons why most derivative works are based on his first book and not the rest. 28/

Fosstodon
@deinol
Ooh, and the gender essentialism; can't leave that out. I quit during the beginning the next book. It was the rant about how horrible liberals are. Not a leftist-socialist rant, mind you; definitely a right wing, libertarian rant, written at the height of the Reagan era.
@deinol
That said, stopping at book 2 might be recommended, but stopping at book 3 would be weird. I didn't think I could have watched Leto become a worm and then been like, yeah I didn't want to see what he does with this.
@deinol I remerber I readd some and I think I should have stopped at first. But, you know gow it is... ;)