Why is it so difficult to reproduce published findings?

Is it differing data processing pipelines or differences in the studied cohorts?

Using 1 processing pipeline, I analyzed 5 datasets on #deepbrainstimulation in Parkinson’s disease.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=280HI2nwiSA

Deep brain stimulation power spectra in Parkinson's disease - Moritz Gerster at NeuralTraces 2024

YouTube

Pro: I reproduced key findings by pooling all cohorts.

Con: Reproduction failed when testing hypotheses on individual datasets.

Takeaway: We need larger and more diverse cohorts to maximize the generalizability of our findings.

Check my talk from #NeuralTraces2024 for a summary of my multi-dataset comparison and an exploration of the significance of theta and low gamma oscillations in #ParkinsonsDisease.

#reproducibility #reproducibilitycrisis #Neuroscience