TFY unwisely agree to Do Something about 70-year-old in-law's laptop, which is 9 years old and running Word 2008 atop a version of macOS unsupported since 2018 …

You have a spare M1 Probook to upgrade him to. What could possibly go wrong?

Well, he's forgotten his login password, never had an AppleID, and his old machine doesn't recognize APFS filesystems for that old-time floppy-style SSD shuffle.

And the cable to the only SSD they have is flaky.

(Now back home, screaming quietly in Mac.)

NOTE: situation is under control, file transfer is happening despite obsolescence (you can't even update his old machine to a new enough macOS to support Migration Assistant transfers to his new mac).

UPDATE: job done.

For all that the Migration Ass. didn't want to work across a 4 OS version mismatch and I had to do everything by hand, I've got the machine sorted. Took hours, but significantly less painful than doing the equivalent job on Windows (don't ask, I speak from experience).

@cstross I've found it... tolerable on more recent versions of windows so long as everything you're running [and care about] is written for the NT branches. Still have to reinstall software from scratch though, the worst of which in my case is the softsynth-and-effect plugin collection much of which wants to be remotely authed the first time it's used as well (these wouldn't be any easier on Mac, ofc).

But there's at least a decent equivalent of /home/ that's actually respected by most software these days, even if you need to know about some of its hidden contents. The 9x branch and software written for it, not so easy.

@cstross As someone who has done that more than a couple of times, I feel your pain. And the sense of accomplishment that is similar to successfully cleaning an outhouse!
@cstross I stupidly wiped a hard drive at the weekend trying to do a clean install of High Sierra. I then had a panic. Eventually I had to use another older Mac (rather than one running the current OS) to download and make a bootable USB. Was slightly stressed!

@cstross OCLP will fix that, if you can be bothered.

https://www.theregister.com/2023/10/09/opencore_legacy_patcher/

The Now Official Mrs Proven's old MacBook is a 2009 model and it's supported by OCLP. In principle I could get it onto macOS >10 easily. Big Sur is the last one to support pre-Metal GPUs. It's doable.

But it's in the basement in Prague and we can't find it. So I hackintoshed macOS 11 onto my old ex-SUSE Dell, restored the Time Machine backup onto that, then copied the files onto a USB HDD and switched the SSD for one with ChromeOS Flex on it. That does all she needs and it's simpler and quicker than macOS.

(This latter made some folks on Reddit very angry with me.)

Apple antique aficionados can boot to the future with OpenCore Legacy Patcher

Hackintoshing reaches a wider audience – owners of older Macs

The Register
@lproven Old machine was 8Gb RAM, a 250Gb SSD ... and a Celeron M. It's not worth keeping.

@cstross @lproven

Yeah, 8GB or RAM and 250GB SSD is actually kinda nice, but Celeron M performance is just too sluggish.

Heck, it was too sluggish when it was new. I think Celeron M laptops weren't able to handle Netflix or YouTube even back in the day.

Even so, I'd personally have uses for it (don't need much CPU or GPU to remote into my work computer, or act as an extra display).

@isaackuo @lproven The only thing the 2015 12" Retina Macbook has going for it, these days, is its weight (it's the lightest non-hackintosh Mac ever made). And I'm sorry, I have a fully loaded M3 Macbook Air now, kthxbye. (It feels subjectively faster than my 10 core i9 iMac.)

@isaackuo @cstross Fake news!

Can attest that my Core 2 Duo 2009 MPB can play YouTube -- my toddler daughter could watch for 2-3 hours, on the original 2009 battery, as of 2022.

Of course a HiDPI screen will need more juice, yes, but a Core M should be significantly faster than a C2D.

@lproven

I wouldn't bet on that.

Passmark for a Celeron M 1.6Ghz is only 190

Passmark for a Core2 Duo E4300 @ 1.80GHz is 593

The E4300 is an older slower Core 2 Duo, and it's still 3x the performance of the best Celeron M.

https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu.php?cpu=Intel+Celeron+M+1.60GHz&id=710

https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu.php?cpu=Intel+Core2+Duo+E4300+%40+1.80GHz&id=1678

@cstross

PassMark - Intel Celeron M 1.60GHz - Price performance comparison

@lproven @isaackuo I think this particular Macbook was a Core-M clocked at 1.2GHz, with 8Gb of RAM (ouch) running El Capitan? (Mine was a 1.6GHz m3 with 16Gb and *that* was unbearably slow.)

@cstross I didn't think Apple ever shipped Celerons?

And as ever, a reminder: these things are relative. Mrs P's MacBook is a Core 2 Duo with 6GB of RAM (I have more but it's *too fast* for the nVidia GPU) and a 120GB SSD.

It flew along in 10.13 and its ~12-year-old battery was good for ~2 hours of disconnected use.

It was a freebie (dropped; dinged case, dead HDD) so I did it up as an experiment. A very successful experiment. It became a daily driver for another couple of years.

@lproven They didn't quite—it was a Core M, in the 12" Retina Macbook, from 2015-2017. (Still totally gutless.) In hindsight, the Macbook cut too many corners (cpu power, battery life) to be useful: today's M3 Macbook Air is only 200g heavier and ridiculously more useful (14 hour battery life, stupidly faster).

@cstross Aha!

I think I tried one in a shop. Not my cuppa: ultra-low travel keyboard, just 1 port, tacky gold option, etc.

But, saying that, for some people it would be a lifesaver.

Apparently it runs Ventura and Sonoma well with OCLP! https://www.reddit.com/r/macbook/comments/178zg1f/updated_my_12_mb_via_opencore/

@lproven I ran one for a couple of years and loved it to bits for its portability EXCEPT for the only-one-USB-C port (back then cheap portable USB-C docks with passthrough charging and an NVMe SSD slot were figments of my imagination) and the lack of power (even Scrivener could make it grind, and Scrivener is infinitely more lightweight than MS Word or just about any web browser).
@cstross I hope @Menhit allowed you to use dd rather than cat this time :)
@cstross target disk mode.. if there is no filevault.

@cstross Well. I just made myself a fool by biking to the PC shop and complaining the harddrive I bought doesn't have a jack fitting the cable.

Turns out that jack is ~so small~ it's nearly invisible amongst the ventilator grate holes.

@cstross

And yet people continue to pay the ridiculous prices that (cr)Apple fleece people with for sub-par systems.

@cstross my default answer to all these sad problems is to lay hands on a large enough external disk, and SuperDuper!

"Mavericks (10.9) users can download v3.1.1, Mountain Lion (10.8) users can download v2.9.2, Lion (10.7) users can download v2.8, Tiger (10.4), Leopard (10.5) and Snow Leopard (10.6) users can download v2.7.1, Jaguar (macOS 10.2) users can download v1.5.5, and Panther (macOS 10.3) users can download v2.1.4, the last releases available for those older versions..."

@dr2chase Did I ask for advice?

(Hint: NO.)

I've been using MacOS since 7.0. I know the drill.

@cstross I'm staring at a 10-year-old Mac aptop in similar shape (Office 2011, macOS Sierra...) and doing actual work on a current one, fortunately. But the old one sits there chuckling at me...

#upgrade #trepidation

@cstross
Apple knows best.
Listen to your Apple.