Can someone explain how it makes sense that an #Opel #eVivaro / #Citroen #eJumpy Crew Cab #EV van (3 second rate seats in the rear) is more expensive, even with fewer features, than the equivalent #Zafira minibus / people carrier with lots of bells and whistles?

Not sure if that’s the case elsewhere, but certainly it is in Finland. It feels like the van versions are 10K more expensive than they should be.

@Setok I can tell you why:

#Lithium-#Batteries are absurdly expensive by their sheer nature - despite the fact that they are peak #UnfairTrade - espechally in terms of #Cobalt.

They wpuld.be cheaper if they were #Methanol #FuelCells and even cheaper if the Economies of Scale would hit that similar.to #Gasoline and #Diesel...

@kkarhan the thing is, these are all electric vehicles. I realise that may not have been obvious from the original post. But the 8 seat #EV #Zafira, with lots of bells and whistles, styling and ‘premium’, is cheaper than a crew cab electric #Vivaro in basic trim! That just doesn’t make sense to me…

@Setok @kkarhan On opel.fi site starting from price for e-Zafira is 1500 euros *higher* than for Vivaro-e. And then there is additional 8000 euros discount for Vivaro-e...

Where did you get your original prices?

@lotneuv @kkarhan check the crew cab prices which is what I'm referring to (and which don't get the government discount :P)

@lotneuv @kkarhan what I suspect may have happened: when the gov introduced the 4K grant for vans, Stellantis bumped up the price accordingly, but of course the Crew Cab couldn't be cheaper than regular, so had to bump that too, making it very weirdly more expensive than the minibus.

Alternatively it could be because businesses have an easier time reclaiming VAT on a van, so Stellantis is taking profit there.

@lotneuv @kkarhan a very different example is the ID.Buzz which, in passenger form, is something like 20K more expensive than the van, making it prohibitively expensive. That's a real bummer as it's almost perfect, but close to 80K for a 2WD vehicle like that is just too much.
@Setok @lotneuv in Fact their #Camper version started at like €80k base and fully decked out went way above €100k.
Compare that to the ample amounts of similar boxy [used] minibuses like Citroen Jumpy, VW T5, Ford Transit and Mercedes Vitaro and then compare to the fact that the #BuzzCamper can barely reach 300km [and that's propably calculated at like 50 km/h continous and neither stop & go nor 100km/h federal roads and highways in Germany] it won't reach the sea on one charge from my location.

@Setok @lotneuv Either way #EVs will continue to be more expensive by virtue of needing more expensive parts and tech compared to equally-spec'd combustion engine driven vehicles.

Even if we'd not have the economies of Scale we'd still have the higher degrees of engineering and necessary parts.

After all, a two-stroke scooter will always be simpler to build than a pedelec, and prices reflect that.

@Setok @lotneuv Whereas #Businesses see vehicles as 'necessary "business expense"' and thus will invest accordingly.

https://mstdn.social/@kkarhan/110888252977037568

Kevin Karhan :verified: (@[email protected])

@[email protected] @[email protected] So basically the same as when #Germany had the bs idea of subsidizing #Gasoline: The #Corporations just upped the prices by the same level... And yes, businesses will just writeoff vans and boxtrucks as business assets if they even buy them instead of leasing them as a complete package which accountants will find easier even if it's more expensive very quickly even without the added value of having services, roadside assistance and replacement vehicles included into the bills.

Mastodon 🐘
@kkarhan @lotneuv I’m not sure I’d go as far as to say that. An EV is actually mechanically simpler than an ICE. It’s just the batteries which push up the price. Electric motors are cheap and simple.

@Setok @lotneuv depends on the exact configuration, but even then the need for more and higher grade rare metals and rare earth minerals make it more expensive.

Because there isn't any fancy need for charging and discharging controllers on anything from a single-cylinder two-stroke to a supercharged V8 Big Block Diesel.

And the lack of #standardization and #ComponentSharing is driving up the prices as well as reduce the economies of scale, since every car has their own custom batteries!

@kkarhan @Setok Best EVs (Tesla, maybe BYD and NIO) have less chips and wires in them as ICE cars with same gear (more stuff done in SW instead of HW).

Tesla and BYD are the first manufacturers to even enter the "economies of scale" scale 😀 Meaning atleast a few hundred thousand items of any particular model manufactured. None of the european brands are there yet - not even VW. And certainly not Stellantis 😜

@kkarhan @Setok If you want a reasonably priced EV it won't be Opel or Citroën. Not for many years IF ever 😐
@lotneuv @kkarhan oh I agree that Tesla is by far the one that makes the most financial sense right now. But they don’t have any utility oriented vehicles (like I’d like to fetch firewood and stuff) and the Cybertruck is only going. G to scale production next year and Europe god knows when…
@Setok @kkarhan There is ofc Maxus but I've heard it sucks and it is not especially cheap 🙂
@lotneuv @kkarhan yeah the Maxus is utterly stupid :D
@lotneuv @kkarhan ‘let’s make a car that’s bad at everything and slap a big price tag on it!’

@Setok @lotneuv

So basically the same as when #Germany had the bs idea of subsidizing #Gasoline: The #Corporations just upped the prices by the same level...

And yes, businesses will just writeoff vans and boxtrucks as business assets if they even buy them instead of leasing them as a complete package which accountants will find easier even if it's more expensive very quickly even without the added value of having services, roadside assistance and replacement vehicles included into the bills.