There's a housing crisis in many cities. But cars can park free. Why not claim public street-space for those who need it? If you disguise your shelter as a polluting, duly-licensed private vehicle, like artist Michael Rakowitz did...
...the authorities should be fine with it.

More on this thought-provoking art project here:

http://www.michaelrakowitz.com/plot-proposition-i

(p)LOT: Proposition I β€” MICHAEL RAKOWITZ

MICHAEL RAKOWITZ
"You'll never be unhoused in Americaβ€”if you're a car."
There are 2 billion parking spaces in the US.
The nation now builds more 3-car garages than 1-bedroom apartments.

In #Brussels, a couple turned street space in front of their apartment into garden, inviting neighbors to plant + harvest what they want.

When cops told them space was meant for cars, they put a license plate on it! They call it "Citizen Garden."

@straphanger it always struck me funny that in many places you can put a car for free but not anything else. As if they're a different ontological order of the being, much more precious than silly things like gardens and sofas.
@batat @straphanger I think about that all the time. People call it parking, but it is just a different name for storage.
@batat @straphanger they are different things? Can i put my car where your sofa is?
@atzanteol
If it fits you can your car where your sofa is. In fact, lots of people put sofas in their garage and vice-versa.
@batat @straphanger
@atzanteol @straphanger I see it's a difficult thing to grasp, but a car at a street occupies 𝑝𝑒𝑏𝑙𝑖𝑐 space, that is, one that should be available to people, while my sofa occupies a π‘π‘Ÿπ‘–π‘£π‘Žπ‘‘π‘’ space, that is, one that should be available only to me. Formal logic and shit. Everybody, including me, should be able to put things in public spaces to put things, while only me should be able to put things where only I can put things.
@batat So society can't designate a particular use for a public space? I can put my trash on your curb? Or in the middle of the streets? Or in the public gardens?

@batat @straphanger I totally understand where you're coming from, but the reason for cars being treated differently is obvious, in my opinion.

Streets are/were primarily built to move cars and trucks. Anything with wheels, really. So "parking" other things on them conflicts with that original ideology.

I think it's great that people are pushing to change that ideology!

@sigue @straphanger and yet I can't just put down my bike on a car parking space. Also, roads were built to move (and host!) people, cars are a very recent (and absolutely cancerous) addition to it.
@batat @straphanger My guess is that even back in the day most roads were built to move carts and buggies and such. The Romans built roads primarily to move their armies quickly.
@sigue @straphanger up until the time of the great lobbying from GM and jaywalking, streets were built as shared spaces.
@batat @straphanger I don't buy it based on two pictures. I see and understand that there are people in the streets. Would they have been built if it weren't for the need to transport goods?
@batat @straphanger https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Street gives some credence to your argument, if we distinguish "street" from "road". I still maintain that the vast majority of streets were built explicitly for cars and virtually nothing else. I am not in any way saying that's a Good Thing.
Street - Wikipedia

@sigue @batat Take a look at the excellent history, "Roads Were Not Built For Cars" by my friend Carlton Reid. Roads, especially outside cities, were paved through the lobbying of cyclists. Cars came much later.

https://www.vox.com/2015/3/19/8253035/roads-cyclists-cars-history

"Roads were not built for cars": how cyclists, not drivers, first fought to pave US roads

Vox

@straphanger @batat That is very cool, but what I see here is that for 30 years rich bicyclists pushed for building roads and then for 110 years since then roads have been built for cars.

So I'm sticking with my original statement that streets are built primarily for cars and trucks.

To repeat, I am 100% in favor of changing that dynamic.

Citizen Garden

A tiny community garden trying to find its place in a city made for cars

@straphanger also, they have a garage door behind, it seems. So, I reckon they should be able to challenge that no one should be allowed to park here in the first place.

@straphanger *left unsaid, rare is the person who wants a 1BR apartment OR the real estate company who wants a 1BR apartment in the portfolio. People want home offices or guest rooms and real estate companies want to give people apartments they can stay with - and that means grow into with families.

This is not surprising!
Let's not make too much of this ratio - which I would actually dispute!

@jann @straphanger

That's why 1 bedroom apartments in NYC, Boston, SF, etc. are so cheap -- nobody wants one!

@rob @straphanger Fine... judge the 1BR's in NYC, Boston, or SF against the number of 3 car garages in those cities.

You'll be found wanting!

That's not the point!

@jann @straphanger
When renting especially if you need Housing Benefit/housing component of Universal Credit 1 bedroom place can be very much needed by many. If you have to claim any form of housing benefit it won't pay for bedrooms the local council HB dept or UC consider you don't need & you are already having to top up your HB as they don't cover all the rent anyway in private rented housing. One of the problems with the bedroom tax on social housing tenants is in most places 1/2
@jann @straphanger
@jann @straphanger
1 bedroom apartments simply haven't been built but you lose housing benefit for living in a 2 bed place even if there are no social housing 1 bed places in the area.
@straphanger this is despicable. I see it in LA all the time. Families with two car garages while people sleep in tents outside
@straphanger "Van Life" is a thing. The people who build box trucks into mobile apartments have a thing going. The ones I've seen are nicer than the first dozen apartments I lived in.
@straphanger And the funny thing is that the cars are mostly parked outside of the garage because the garage is full of stuff... ;)
@straphanger could self driving cars change this? They only need to be present when we need them. Other times they can go away on their own, perhaps to a central facility, and wait to be called.
@straphanger please show source of data on num of parking spaces. Possibly true.

@straphanger

I love a bit of lateral thinking.

I personally don't like streets cluttered with cars though.

@straphanger and then someone who sucks at parking runs over your skull while you sleep…
@straphanger wow. How useful this would be in #sanfrancisco Tenderloin district!
@benplumley @straphanger why only the tenderloin district? This can be done throughout SF.
@straphanger but if it were licensed, it would be paying taxes for the road it is on

@straphanger
Bulk #AltText for all images above:

Tent in the same shape and appearance as a car.

@straphanger really cool and really sad at the same time
@straphanger how clever. Thank you for sharing. I’ll talk about this on my show.

@straphanger sadly, this would not be tolerated as it's not a #licensed & #insuranced vehicle.

It would be however tolerated if it was in fact a licensed cabin scooter like a Piaggio Ape 50.

Furthermore most juristictions ban sleeping in cars...

Brent Toderian (@[email protected])

Attached: 1 image β€œIn #Finland, the number of homeless people has fallen sharply. Those affected receive a small apartment and counselling with no preconditions. 4 out of 5 people affected make their way back into a stable life. And all this is CHEAPER than accepting homelessness.” Make sure everyone understands this β€” It’s costing us far too much to NOT provide housing and supports to those who are homeless. https://scoop.me/housing-first-finland-homelessness/ #homelessness #cities #housing #HousingFirst

Mastodon
@straphanger except of course, cars don't park for free, anymore than "free at the point of care" healthcare systems are "free". Fuel tax, sales tax, road tax etc. are all part of it. It's been encouraged in the US to maintain economic growth. You can argue that it's a political decision with more negatives than positives (from ecological downsides to poisoning people with fumes, to helping people stay fat and lazy) and I'd personally agree... but my only provoked thought is "lazy and dumb art".
@straphanger I think about this all the time walking through cities, here I created a small infographic for my home town #Vienna.
@straphanger Hm. Have you met authorities?

@straphanger this would just have rich assholes driving over homeless people.

Terrible idea

@straphanger san diego manages to fine ppl who stay overnight in their cars or leave the car parked in same spot 72+ hours. (not the solution of course, and plenty of subsidized parking otherwise). post-covid streateries now pay a fee to keep their outdoor spots on the former parking strips. i think recognition that this isn't "free" is growing but we need to think about how best to use it

@straphanger @drewharwell While I understand the statement being made, this doesn't work out in reality.

Here in Oakland, we have massive streetside encampments, some in RVs, some in tents or makeshift shelters. They quickly become public health hazards and fire dangers; people have died in fires.

The homeless don't just need space, they need support & healthcare. "Let them use the parking spaces instead" is a very Marie Antoinette attitude to take.

@straphanger
In Germany not allowed.
Sleeping in your car on public ground is prohibited. There is only one exception - when you need to rest to be able to continue your trip.

But great idea.

@straphanger hi, can you please add image descriptions? I love this art project and would boost your post if you edited in descriptions for accessibility.

Here's a good guide to writing them, but really, any effort at all is better than nothing. https://uxdesign.cc/how-to-write-an-image-description-2f30d3bf5546

How to write an image description

I wrote this how-to guide with the immensely helpful counsel and insights from Bex Leon and Robin Fanning, as well as through an online…

Medium