M Disc for archival durability. Tests and review.

An extensive test and review of M Disk archival durability.

I archive my photos on blu-ray m-discs.

I had a burner that I used less than 10 times a couple of years ago and found it that has died on me. I was told that there are rubber components that break if you don't use the device regularly.

Does this sound right to you guys? I don't want to buy a new drive every other year!

#backup #mdisc #bluray #plannedobsolescence

Once again considering usage of optical media (#DVD or #BD, likely #MDisc) for personal #backups. Usually I encrypt all the backups, using LUKS or ZFS's encryption, but unsure about those on optical media: does it work with Linux to prepare a LUKS image, with UDF on top, and burn that onto a disk? Or is it easier to prepare an encrypted file, to be mounted as a loop device on reading, and write it on top of UDF? I also wonder how well-supported such external drives are by Linux, whether it is on the painful side of compatibility.

Also trying to choose between DVD and BD. I see very few external BD drives in local stores (possibly because those are also harder to power, requiring two USB cables) and those are more expensive, but apparently the Blu-ray disks themselves are supposed to last longer, it must be more convenient to use larger-capacity disks, and the M-DISC ones I see in local stores are all BD.

As a side note, I discovered that while it is hard to find computer cases with proper HDD bays these days, those show up in online stores' listings once you add a filter condition for external 5.25-inch bays. As a bonus, apparently those tend to not be covered in LEDs.

#archiving data on BD-R XL #MDisc
Bought the more expensive discs to ensure to preseverve the data for at least the next century. Here is a picture of the media before and after burning it. Of course the disc can‘t be read anymore.

@felsqualle @fuchsiii that's because around 2010s they cheaped out with organic binder (same shit as #LaserDisc used) and decided that's good enough.

  • Consider imaging your stuff and/or using #MDISC recordables...

#DiscRot

@felsqualle @fuchsiii yeah, you guys can thank the folks who thought it was a great idea to use the same organic binder as used in the #LaserDisc...

  • If you need optical archives, consider buying #MDISC recordables...

@raccoon what kind of discs?

#BDXL-#MDISC|s?

I mean I'd love to be able to afford an #LTO9 - #TapeDrive...

Another one for the #archive #datahoarder #storage #nas bubble:

What is the ~best DVD-ROM drive to read old and likely degraded media?

The Internet at large seems devoid of any information, it's all AI and linkfarming slop.

Are #MDisc worth it? If yes, what drive, disk manufacturer etc do I want? Are 100GB discs are reliable as 50 and 25 ones?
#HDD have shorter life? #LTO #tape seems less portable?

CC @internetarchive @textfiles @brewsterkahle

Retoots and replies *very* much appreciated.

🧵 6/n next time, i won't be double-compressing my #MDISC #BDXL #backup.

I can't use the disc image directly, because in my infinite wisdom, i've compressed the already compressed file system.

Now i get to wait another hour-ish, before i can access my rather old files.

Well, i can try and scrape 'em off the busted NVMe.

I just learned about bluray m-discs, and now I want to use them for long-term backups. I realise I have no followers, but does anyone have any advice for (Windows) software to write the discs? #MDisc #backup #bluray