Why genAI means the end of copyright for software and the re-invention of open source

Most of the discussions about the impact of the latest generative AI systems on copyright have centred on text, images and video. That’s no surprise, since writers, artists and film-makers feel very strongly about their creations, and members of the public can relate easily to the issues that AI raises for this kind of creativity. But there’s another creative domain that has been massively […]

#ai #chardet #circumvention #claude #cleanRoom #danBlanchard #genai #gnu #gpl #lgpl #licensing #markPilgrim #mit #nebraskaProblem #openSource #openSource20 #python #richardStallman #software #unix https://walledculture.org/why-genai-means-the-end-of-copyright-for-software-and-the-re-invention-of-open-source/
Hope of AGPL Licenser by Bovas De Quincey, an autobiography.

#agpl
#fsf
#gnu
#gpl
#lgpl
#richardmatthewstallman
#richardstallman
#rms
#stallmanwasright

@knowprose

You're speculating on the reasons #SCOTUS denied cert. There is nothing in their denial that supports your argument.

The big picture stakes are high (of course). Focusing on a year-old case as if it actually tells us something new merely because SCOTUS denied cert is just a mechanism for spreading FUD.

Here's a full analysis of the entire DC Circuit Ruling:
https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2026/mar/04/scotus-deny-cert-dc-circuit-thaler-appeal-llm-ai/

Cc: @downey

#AI #LLM #copyleft #GPL #LGPL

SCOTUS Declines to Hear LLM-Backed AI Case Regarding Copyright

No Serious Implications for FOSS from SCOTUS' DenialEarlier this week1, the U.S. Supreme Court (SCOTUS) denied certiorari (cert) in Thaler v. Perlmutter. Thaler contended that an image — generated by a Large Language Model (LLM)-backed Artificial Intelligence (AI) — deserved copyright registration. Since the U.S. Copyright Office refused to grant the registration, Thaler appealed to the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia (DC Circuit). That Court affirmed the Copyright Office's decision. SCOTUS' denial of “cert” means they will not hear the case. Strictly speaking, this denial does not affirm the DC Circuit Court's ruling, but it does mean the DC Circuit decision stands.

Software Freedom Conservancy

@soller I'm relying primarily on hard-work, regular research, and constant vigilance, not luck and not FUD.

It is not time to panic.

I urge folks to read what #SFC has published on #LLM's & #AI

The biggest problem we have is the funding gap between those of us trying to save #copyleft & those who are creating the problem.

We'll need less luck and be able to more easily apply the other skills I mentioned if folks support #SoftwareFreedom Conservancy.

https://sfconservancy.org/sustainer/

#GPL #LGPL

Support Conservancy!

Software freedom is critical to many of today’s most pressing social issues, but it’s only effective when FOSS is for everyone. Support Conservancy today to help make that happen!

Software Freedom Conservancy

OP (see uphtread) has misunderstood this (year old) Court ruling quite a bit.

It's ok—we all make mistakes. The important task now is to correct the mistake.
I encourage boosting of this reply to address & draw attention boost to the prior error.
I assure you #copyleft (& software itself) *are not* seriously impacted by this ruling, and #SFC remains constantly vigilant on these matters.

https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2026/mar/04/scotus-deny-cert-dc-circuit-thaler-appeal-llm-ai/

IANAL but AFAIK @soller isn't either.
Cc: @downey
#LLM #AI #legal #Court #GPL #LGPL

SCOTUS Declines to Hear LLM-Backed AI Case Regarding Copyright

No Serious Implications for FOSS from SCOTUS' DenialEarlier this week1, the U.S. Supreme Court (SCOTUS) denied certiorari (cert) in Thaler v. Perlmutter. Thaler contended that an image — generated by a Large Language Model (LLM)-backed Artificial Intelligence (AI) — deserved copyright registration. Since the U.S. Copyright Office refused to grant the registration, Thaler appealed to the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia (DC Circuit). That Court affirmed the Copyright Office's decision. SCOTUS' denial of “cert” means they will not hear the case. Strictly speaking, this denial does not affirm the DC Circuit Court's ruling, but it does mean the DC Circuit decision stands.

Software Freedom Conservancy

Salvatore Sanfilippo (@antirez) and Armin Ronacher (@mitsuhiko) both argue that #AI reimplementation of #copyleft libraries is fine. Their legal reasoning might be correct. That's not the point.

Legal and legitimate are different things—and both pieces quietly assume otherwise.

https://writings.hongminhee.org/2026/03/legal-vs-legitimate/

#GPL #LGPL #license #opensource #freesoftware

Is legal the same as legitimate: AI reimplementation and the erosion of copyleft

Last week, Dan Blanchard, the maintainer of chardet—a Python library for detecting text encodings used by roughly 130 million projects a month— released a new…

Hong Minhee on Things
Chardet : quand une IA réécrit un logiciel open source en cinq jours et change sa licence - Korben

Le développeur Dan Blanchard a utilisé Claude d'Anthropic pour réécrire intégralement chardet, une bibliothèque Python téléchargée 130 millions de fois par ...

Le site de Korben

¹ At #SCaLE2026, #SFC is again the Network Sponsor. For the 2nd year, the entire #SCaLE network is operating on #OpenWrt One's — the only wireless router hardware in history to comply with #GPL & #LGPL from Day 0 *&* have no proprietary software² for its operating system & UI.

Want One? Visit #SoftwareFeedom Conservancy's booth (on left entering expo hall) to buy One (while supplies last).

Not at #SCaLE? https://sfconservancy.org/activities/openwrt-one.html

²It does have binary blobs on some components.

#FOSS #OpenSource

OpenWrt One -

The Software Freedom Conservancy provides a non-profit home and services to Free, Libre and Open Source Software (FLOSS) projects.

#Chardet : quand une #IA réécrit un logiciel #opensource #foss en cinq jours et change sa #licence , sans vergogne de #LGPL à #MIT ... Vide #juridique total... korben.info/chardet-quan...

Chardet : quand une IA réécrit...
Chardet : quand une IA réécrit un logiciel open source en cinq jours et change sa licence - Korben

Le développeur Dan Blanchard a utilisé Claude d'Anthropic pour réécrire intégralement chardet, une bibliothèque Python téléchargée 130 millions de fois par ...

Le site de Korben