Robert Leonard (bef. 1730 – 1780): Testimony of Thomas Dunlap Leonard’s “Biography of the Leonards” (1883)
Thomas Dunlap Leonard, “Biography of the Leonards” (1883), typescript of a manuscript whose present whereabouts have not been determined
Robert Leonard (bef. 1730 – 1780) is one of the more problematic of my ancestors to sort out. There’s actually a goodly selection of documents providing first-hand information about his life. These include the following:
• A bible that appears originally to have belonged to Robert and wife Honor Pritchard Leonard
• A document showing him discharged from the British military unit HM 35th Regiment at a date only partly stated
• A document showing him indenturing his son William in Frederick County, Virginia, in 1755
• A power of attorney made by his widow Honor and other family members in 1800 stating Robert’s military service in the French and Indian and Revolutionary Wars
• A trail of documents including muster lists, payment records, and other records capturing Robert’s service under John Dagworthy and Alexander Beall in western Maryland during the French and Indian War
• A generally very reliable family history written in 1883 by Robert’s great-grandson Thomas Dunlap Leonard, which incorporates information told to him by his grandparents, Robert’s son Thomas and wife Hannah James
• Documents chronicling his enlistment in the 7th Maryland Regiment during the Revolutionary War, and his death in 1780 in the battle of Camden
A treasure trove of documents, then: but they’re in many ways the source of the problem of understanding his life story: they do not always cohere. They sometimes contradict each other. And two of the documents that have survived, the bible record and his military discharge, are partially destroyed and obscured, so that making out what they say is a real challenge.
Nor do any of the first-hand documents providing information about Robert Leonard tell us important pieces of information like when and where he was born, where he married, whether he was born Maryland where we have solid documentation of his presence by 1755, or whether he was born elsewhere. Was he, as many of his descendants have thought, an immigrant, born outside the American colonies? Even that’s not clear from the sources we have to work with.
There’s additional confusion about which of his sons was the oldest and when that son was born, confusion even about the names of his sons. We have a well-documented birthdate of 15 October 1752 for Thomas, who seems not to have been the oldest son. In 1755, Robert indentured his son William, who must have been born by at least 1750, one would think, to have been indentured in 1755.[1] It appears William was older than Thomas and was likely Robert’s oldest son, but — problems piled on problems — the list of Robert’s sons provided by In his 1883 account of the Leonard family, Thomas Dunlap Leonard does not even mention William, but speaks of a Samuel who seems to have been non-existent!
Explanations are in order….
Thomas Dunlap Leonard’s “Biography of the Leonards”
As previous postings have noted (and here), a major source for information about the family descending from Robert Leonard is an 1883 manuscript entitled “Biography of the Leonards,” which was written by Thomas Dunlap Leonard (1810-1888), a son of Robert Leonard (1777-1844) and Rachel Dunlap. Robert Leonard with wife Rachel was a son of Thomas Leonard (1752-1832) and Hannah James. As a previous series of postings indicates, Thomas was a son of Robert Leonard (bef. 1730 – 1780), the progenitor of this line of American Leonards.
As the postings linked at the start of the preceding paragraph note, Thomas Dunlap Leonard grew up in Lincoln (later Marshall) County, Tennessee, living near his grandparents Thomas Leonard and Hannah James, and much of what he recorded about the first generations of this family came from information his grandparents shared with him. Here’s what Thomas D. Leonard has to say about Robert Leonard and his wife Honor Pritchard:
I shall give the life of Robert in the War of 1760 between England and France. He fought with England as well all the colonies in America was under the English government. He was at the Battle of Quebec. His discharge as a soldier of the English Army is yet in existence. It is in the family of Griffith Leonard in Tenn.; and I have seen it.
When the war took place between England and the colonies of America, he rebelled against England and fought with America and was killed at the battle of Camden, leaving a widow with four children. He married an English lady named Honor Pritchard, early after her arrival to America. We have not the history of the Prichard [sic] family. She brought up her four children in Maryland, giving a limited education, such as the opportunities of the times afforded of that age, yet of one thing we are sure that she was a lady of great moral worth of character, from the moral training that her children exhibited in their lives. Through a long life it has been my privilege to live with, and enjoy their society for twenty-five years of my life.
According to the testimony of his great-grandson Thomas D. Leonard, then, Robert Leonard the immigrant ancestor was “a soldier of the English Army” who took part in the “War of 1760 between England and France.” Note that Thomas D. Leonard does not state that Robert Leonard arrived in the American colonies as a British soldier. Generations of Robert’s descendants have concluded this, but this conclusion reads into the text something that Thomas D. Leonard does not actually say.
Thomas D. Leonard specifically says that Robert Leonard took part in the “War of 1760” as a soldier in the English army and participated in the battle of Québec. The pivotal event of that battle was the battle of the Plains of Abraham on 13 September 1759, which resulted in the capitulation of Québec to British forces on 18 September.
As we’ll see down the road, Robert Leonard’s paper discharging him from service in HM 35th Regiment of Foot provides a strong basis for concluding that Robert did, indeed, take part in this military action in Canada in 1759, and served in the 35th from some point prior to that date until he was discharged in Havana on 24 September 1762. But a stream of documents prior to the end of the 1750s show him, prior to this point, serving as a sergeant at Fort Frederick under General John Dagworthy in the defense of Maryland’s western frontier. So he did not arrive in America as a soldier in the English 35th Regiment, but joined that regiment after some years of service under Dagworthy in Maryland. Both at Fort Frederick and in the 35th, his rank was sergeant, as it was later during the Revolution. There’s strong reason to believe that Robert, who does not appear owning land in Frederick County, was a professional soldier throughout his adult life.
But the claim that Robert arrived in the colonies as a soldier of the English army gets the chronology of his military service backwards and reads into Thomas D. Leonard’s family history something Thomas does not say, namely, that Robert was serving in the 35th Regiment when he came to Maryland. He joined that English military unit only after having spent most of the 1750s already doing military service under Dagworthy at Fort Frederick and, apparently prior to the construction of Fort Frederick, at Fort Cumberland. I suspect that the reason Thomas D. Leonard speaks of Robert Leonard serving in the “War of 1760,” taking part in the battle of Québec, and then goes on to say that Robert was a “soldier of the English Army” is that he wants to draw attention to Robert’s service in the portion of the French and Indian War that occurred in Canada in 1759-1760 with the capitulation first of Québec in 1759 and then of Montréal in 1760, and with the 35th Regiment playing a well-documented role in these actions. As we’ve seen previously, the power of attorney that Robert’s widow Honor and sons Thomas and Robert along with Honor’s son-in-law Colin Campbell made in September 1800 states that Robert was a “Sergeant in the war of 1753” — that is, in the earlier years of the French and Indian War where we have good documentation of his service in western Maryland in the colonial troops commanded by John Dagworthy.
As a previous posting has noted, there’s documentary evidence that Robert was in Maryland by 1755 when he indentured his son William there in Frederick County. He was almost certainly in Maryland by 1752 when his son Thomas was born. The posting I’ve just linked shows that various records place Robert Leonard at Fort Frederick some eighteen miles west of Hagerstown in the 1750s. Prior to that, he would have been at Fort Cumberland in 1755 when he indentured his son William, stating that he was “a soldier in Captain Dagurthey’s Company.” Construction began on Fort Frederick in 1756 and was completed the following year.[2] Prior to this point, Dagworthy’s troops were at Fort Cumberland on the Potomac west of Fort Frederick. As the posting I’ve just linked also notes, on the 1880 federal census, the one living child of Thomas Leonard and Hannah James, their daughter Hannah, reported that both of her parents were born in Maryland. If this is accurate information (and I see no reason to challenge it), then Robert and Honor Pritchard Leonard were living in Maryland by 1752 when their son thomas was born.
There’s sound documentary evidence, then, backing Thomas D. Leonard’s statement that Robert Leonard was a soldier involved in the war between England and France. This information undoubtedly came to him from his grandparents Thomas and Hannah James Leonard, and, as he goes on to say, he had seen the papers discharging Robert Leonard from his British military service, which were kept by Thomas Leonard and then his son Griffith James Leonard. I’ll discuss those discharge papers in more detail down the road.
As I’ve noted, the 12 September 1800 power of attorney given by Robert Leonard’s widow Honor and sons Thomas and Robert with son-in-law Colin Campbell provides yet another layer of proof of Robert Leonard’s military service in Maryland during the French and Indian War. The linked posting provides a digital image and transcription of this document, noting that the Leonards gave power of attorney to James Irwin of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, to obtain any pay still due Robert Leonard for his service in both the French and Indian and Revolutionary War. About Robert’s military service in the two wars, the power of attorney states that he was,
Formerly Sergeant in the war of 1753 Genl. Washinton’s first Ridgiment and in the Late American war with Britain in the Maryland Ridgiment as Sergeant till killd. in Genl. Gatises Defiat.
Regarding the claim that Robert Leonard was a sergeant in General Washington’s first regiment in the “war of 1753”: as I’ve noted previously, I think this statement may be referencing tensions between John Dagworthy and Washington as the French and Indian War got underway and as Fort Frederick was constructed, and confusion about exactly who was in command at the two forts at which Robert Leonard was posted in the 1750s. As the posting I’ve just linked explains, in the fall of 1755, Virginia took possession of Fort Cumberland, where Dagworthy and his troops were stationed, and this placed Dagworthy on what historian Eric Sterner calls a “collision course” with Washington.[3] Washington was considered to be in charge of the fort, but Dagworthy saw him as a young upstart and refused to submit to his command.
As construction began on Fort Frederick in July 1756, Washington visited that fort, and in June 1758, he returned to the fort during his campaign to capture Fort Duquesne. All during these years, with documentary evidence that Dagworthy paid Robert Leonard for service up to March 1763,[4] there was interaction, usually hostile on the side of Dagworthy, between John Dagworthy and George Washington. And there were questions about who was in command of whom, so that confusion about whether Robert Leonard was serving under Dagworthy or Washington for part of this period of time is understandable. I’ll say more about these matters in a subsequent section of this overview of Robert Leonard’s life focusing specifically on his military service in the French and Indian War.
Thomas Dunlap Leonard’s “Biography of the Leonards” also tells us another important piece of information about Robert Leonard’s early years in the American colonies: he states that Robert “married an English lady named Honor Pritchard, early after her arrival to America.” Note that Thomas D. Leonard doesn’t state either when this marriage took place or where the couple married. A partly obscured item in the register of the bible have belonged to Robert and then his son Thomas — I’ll discuss the bible in detail later — states a 1747 date for some event that is obscured, and some Leonard researchers have suggested that this is a record of the date of Robert and Honor’s marriage, though much of this record is water-damaged and illegible.
I have no clue, by the way, why some Leonard descendants want to give Honor’s surname as Sellers when Thomas D. Leonard plainly states that it was Pritchard. I see no compelling reason to doubt Thomas D. Leonard’s testimony on this point. I strongly suspect that piece of information came to him from his grandparents Thomas and Hannah James Leonard.
Thomas D. Leonard offers one other interesting piece of information about Robert Leonard’s son-in-law Colin Campbell, who married Robert’s daughter Mary: he states, “This man was a British soldier.” Colin wouldn’t have been in service alongside Robert, since Colin was born in 1754 and was a generation younger than Robert. But since Robert Leonard appears to have been a professional soldier who served in the British army in the late 1750s and early 1760s, it seems worth noting that his son-in-law was yet another British soldier.
Finally, Thomas D. Leonard names the children of Robert Leonard and Honor Pritchard:
Robert was the oldest child, then Thos., then Samuel, then Mary.
This statement presents us with another conundrum: as I stated previously, we know for certain that by 8 February 1755, Robert Leonard had a son named William. We know this because the indenture he made on that date states that William Leonard, whom he was indenturing, was his son. The indenture contract does not state William’s age, unfortunately. But to be apprenticed in 1755, he has to have been more than a mere infant. Children as young as seven or eight years of age could be and sometimes were indentured in this period. It seems very likely that William was born prior to 1750 and was perhaps Robert Leonard’s oldest son.[5]
But Thomas D. Leonard makes no mention at all of a son William. He speaks, instead, of a son Samuel for whom no records seem to exist. “Biography of the Leonards” goes on to say that Samuel remained in Pendleton District, South Carolina, after Robert’s widow Honor and her children Thomas and Mary (Campbell) moved to Tennessee in 1808 or 1809 with Robert following soon after and with Samuel dying in South Carolina leaving, according to Thomas D. Leonard, children George, Samuel, Elizabeth, and Belinda.
A William Leonard died testate in Pendleton District, South Carolina, in 1811 with a will dated 12 February 1811, probated 29 March 1811.[6] That will names as William’s executor a son George, and names younger children Elizabeth, Samuel, Mary Ann, Agnes, and Honor Malinda. This William Leonard is, it’s clear, the man of that name who arrived in Pendleton District almost simultaneously with Thomas Leonard and the other members of the Leonard family who moved from Washington County, Maryland, to Pendleton District in 1786. As a previous posting notes, after Thomas Leonard had a survey on the Big Generostee in Pendleton District on 9 February 1786, William Leonard also had a survey of 200 acres just north of Thomas’ survey on 21 February 1786.[7]
From 1786 through 1811, it’s fairly easy to document William Leonard’s life in Pendleton District, with document after document suggesting that he’s closely related to Thomas and Robert and their sister Mary Leonard Campbell. Thomas D. Leonard’s manuscript says that “Samuel’s” son George came to Tennessee to live with his Leonard relatives there, and there’s documentary evidence of George’s presence among those relatives in Tennessee.
But until William Leonard’s son Samuel came of age in Pendleton District around 1815, there’s nary mention of any Samuel Leonard in the records of Pendleton District, while there are copious references to a William Leonard who appears to be the same man as the Samuel identified as a son of Robert and Honor Pritchard Leonard in Thomas D. Leonard’s “Biography of the Leonards.” Thomas D. Leonard seems to be mistaken in stating that Robert Leonard had a son Samuel. Robert did, however, have a documented son William born prior to 1755 who appears to be the William Leonard who shows up in Pendleton District by 1786 when other members of the Leonard family arrived there from Maryland. I suspect William was the oldest son of Robert Leonard.[8]
Why Thomas D. Leonard would have made this mistake about the children of Robert Leonard and Honor Pritchard, I’m not sure, except that he knew personally the other three children of Robert and Honor Leonard, since he grew up near all of them in Tennessee and, later, Alabama — and he did not know the one child of Robert and Honor who remained behind in South Carolina. And, again, if Thomas was the second son of Robert and Honor and we can document that he was born in 1752, then it seems likely that if William was Thomas’ elder, he was born prior to 1750 — a birthdate also suggested by the 1755 indenture record.
About Thomas D. Leonard’s claim that Robert was the oldest child of Robert Leonard and Honor Pritchard: I have not found any firm documentation of Robert’s birthdate. The 1790 federal census, enumerating him in Pendleton District, South Carolina, simply shows him aged above 16 years.[9] In 1800, also in Pendleton District, he’s aged 26-44.[10] In 1810, still in Pendleton District, Robert’s age category is again 26-44.[11] The 1820 federal census has him, now in Lincoln County, Tennessee, aged over 45.[12] And the 1830 federal census, also enumerating him in Lincoln County and the last federal census on which he appears, shows him aged 60-69.[13] If that census has a correct birth entry for Robert, he was born between 1760 and 1769 and was younger than his brothers William and Thomas.
In my next posting surveying documents that tell the story of Robert Leonard, I’ll provide an in-depth look at Robert’s the register of the bible that originally belonged to Robert and wife Honor and to the document discharging him from service in HM 35th Regiment.
[1] Frederick County, Maryland, Land Record Bk. E, pp. 659-660.
[2] See Debra R. Boender, “Fort Frederick (Maryland),” in Colonial Wars of North America, 1512-1763: An Encyclopedia, ed. Alan Gallay (Oxford: Routledge, 1996), pp. 236-7;“Frederick, Fort,” in Encyclopedia of the French and Indian War in North America, 1754-1763, ed. Donald I. Stoelzel (Westminster, Maryland: Heritage Books, 2008), p. 160; Maryland Park Service, “Fort Frederick State Park History,” at website of Maryland Department of Natural Resources; and “Fort Frederick,” in Forts of the United States: An Historical Dictionary, 16th Through 19th Centuries, ed. Bud Hannings (Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland, 2006), p. 193.
[3] Eric Sterner, “General John Dagworthy: George Washington’s Forgotten American Rival,” Journal of the American Revolution (online; 11 October 2017). See also George W. Marshall, Memoir of Brigadier-General John Dagworthy of the Revolutionary War (Wilmington: Historical Society of Delaware, 1895), pp. 13-15; “General John Dagworthy,” in Biographical and Genealogical History of the State of Delaware, vol. 1 (Chambersburg, Pennsylvania: J.M. Runk, 1899), pp. 105-6; “Dagworthy Controversy,” at The Ladies of Mount Vernon’s George Washington’s Mount Vernon website; and “John Dagworthy” at Wikipedia.
[4] Henry C. Peden Jr., Marylanders and Delawareans in the French and Indian War 1756-1763 (Lewes, Delaware: Colonial Roots, 2004).
[5] The indenture document specifically states that Robert was indenturing his son William for fourteen years and seven months. When minors were indentured in Maryland at this period, the limit of indenture was usually up to their 21st birthday. If the indenture period is an indicator of William’s age at the time Robert indentured him, he would have been six years and five months old in February 1755, and therefore born in September 1748.
[6] Anderson County, South Carolina, Will Bk. A, pp. 129-130.
[7] South Carolina Plat Books (Charleston Series), vol. 15, p. 127; and Ninety-Six District, South Side of Saluda, Commissioner of Locations Plat Bk. B, p. 113.
[8] A thought that occurs to me, purely conjectural: could William have been a son of Robert Leonard born prior to Robert’s marriage to Honor Pritchard? If so, might that fact explain why Robert indentured a young son out in 1755 after he married Honor, by whom he had a son Thomas born in 1752? Perhaps Honor did not want to raise a son of Robert born to some other mother…. As I say, this is purely conjectural and should be taken as such.
[9] 1790 federal census, Pendleton District, South Carolina, p. 5. The surname is spelled Lennard.
[10] 1800 federal census, Pendleton District, South Carolina, p. 7.
[11] 1810 federal census, Pendleton District, South Carolina, p. 143. The surname is Leanard.
[12] 1820 federal census, Lincoln County, Tennessee, p. 11.
[13] 1830 federal census, Lincoln County, Tennessee, p. 190.
#AgnesLeoanrd #BattleOfCamdenSouthCarolina #BattleOfPlainsOfAbrahamQuébecCanada #BattleOfQuébec #CimberlandCoPennsylvania #ColinCampbell #ElizabethLeonard #familyHistory #FortCumberlandAlleganyCoMaryland #FortDuquesnePennsylvania #FortFrederickWashingtonCoMaryland #FrederickCoMaryland #FrenchAndIndianWar #genealogy #GeorgeLeonard #GeorgeWashington #HagerstownWashingtonCoMaryland #HannahJames #HavanaCuba #history #HonorMalindaLeonard #HonorPritchard #JamesIrwin #JohnDagworthy #LincolnCoTennessee #MarshallCoTennessee #MaryLeonard #Maryland #MontréalCanada #PendletonDistSouthCarolina #QuébecCanada #RachelDunlap #RobertLeonard #SamuelLeonard #ThomasDunlapLeonard #ThomasLeonard #WashingtonCoMaryland #WilliamLeonard
BEGATS AND BEQUEATHALS
The New York Times - Breaking News, US News, World News and Videos [Unofficial]
Travel
Fight Back! News
Zoom Zoom Nomad
Francisco Litardo
Matt