"When the only thing stopping you from completely dehumanising someone is your own judgement regarding their privilege level relative to yours, you are not a safe person to be around."
Relevant: The foaming-at-the-mouth MAGA mirrorshadesdudes and the reasonable, kind, limitless-love MAGA housewives truly believe they are "punching up" when they vote for candidates who promise to hurt marginalized people.
We can stop bad policies and oppose bad behavior without demonizing or dehumanizing the people associated with that behavior.
(I'm reassured that some random person from tumblr said what I've tried to say, but much more concisely and memorably. I also realize that I'm hypocritically struggling with this myself--I believe it in my mind even though in my heart I want to punch all the nazis.)
[The text from the image is below]
sluglover666: Hot take, but even if you ARE punching up (instead of punching sideways at a group that is in the same boat as you), there's a limit to what you can say without sounding like a violent facist but woke this time.
Making fun of a group of people that are privileged over you is one thing, but wishing non-cartoonish violence and death on them ("they should fall off a cliff" vs. "they should be wiped out"), wishing sexual violence on them, dehumanising them, claiming that they're less capable of creating art or living meaningful lives, saying that their relationships are inherently shallow and fake - these things are fucked up. I understand venting and saying extreme things when in pain, but when you find yourself regularly posting about wanting certain people tortured and killed, you need to examine that.
(Post is long because text from image pasted at bottom)
When the only thing stopping you from completely dehumanising someone is your own judgement regarding their privilege level relative to yours, you are not a safe person to be around.
darkladynyara quoting royalhenoil: For real, this "anything goes so long as it's punching up" was a driving force in the Rwandan Genocide. The people who perpetrated the genocide believed they were punching up.
emfrots: "convince your followers that their Oppressor Class (whether real or imagined) is less deserving of human rights" is the oldest and most reliable trick in the book to incite mass violence, and you're not immune to it because you're a Good Person with Correct Opinions




