I'm trying to get my friend started with a smart home and I'm really struggling with what to recommend for a mesh network. On the one hand Zigbee seems to be incredibly mature and reliable, but it requires a hub. On the other hand, Thread seems nice because it only needs border routers which can be distributed, but the devices are more expensive and seem to be less reliable.
I really want to keep to Matter as much as possible because I love the multi-admin mode, so I'm torn. My friend is getting into Home Assistant, but his husband really likes using their Google Home speakers, so I want to be able to put devices into both. Basically, my options are:
1) Get Matter over Thread devices.
2) Get a Zigbee hub that supports Matter.
3) Use Home Assistant as a Zigbee hub and use Matterbridge.
I'd love some thoughts or feedback if anyone has any, or maybe some options I missed.
#HomeAssistant #HomeAutomation #Matter #Thread #Zigbee #Mesh



