Benanav vs Morozov on the Political Economy of AI. Now, this will definitely be quite a read...!
"Choosing among available paths may widen or contract the field of possibilities. Some futures are rendered easier to realize; others are effectively foreclosed; and peopleās understandings of what matters shift as they move forward in timeāmuch as in Morozovās own account of technological worldmaking. The difference is that, in my framework, this process is understood from the outset as political because it unfolds under conditions of scarcity that force collective choice among rival futures.
What is puzzling about Morozovās critique is that this political core disappears from view. A framework designed to organize conflict over investmentāto make trade-offs visible, contestable, and binding when not everything can be pursued at onceāis recast as a system of administrative closure that would prematurely discipline experimentation. His analysis is not simply a misunderstanding of my proposed framework but a reversal of its intent: It reads an account meant to politicize worldmaking as an attempt to suppress it."
https://www.theideasletter.org/essay/a-real-political-economy-of-technology/
#AI #GenerativeAI #PoliticalEconomy #Democratization #PublicPolicy #Municipalism #GreenTransition #Communitarianism