BERLIN
As Donald Trump’s erratic messaging increasingly resembles a strategy of throwing ketchup at the wall and seeing how much of it sticks, one attack line looks especially unhinged: the accusation, most notably in tweets by Trump and his new superfan Elon Musk with AI-generated fake images, that Vice President Kamala Harris is a Communist or a Marxist.
Yes, as if it were 1950 and Sen. Joseph McCarthy of Wisconsin had just flourished his first list of alleged Communists lurking in the State Department.
That notion is idiotic on its face. A member of the Democratic Party suggesting that companies can abuse power and that governments should act to prevent those actions and address their consequences is not in the same neighborhood, Zip code or state as advocating collective ownership of the means of production under the dictatorship of the proletariat. Higher marginal tax rates and more stringent consumer-protection laws do not constitute the imposition of Marxist-Leninism, no matter how much you might hate to pay the former or live under the economic consequences of the latter.
That comparison is especially offensive here, in this city that documents the crimes of the Communist regime of the German “Democratic” “Republic” in places like the Berlin Wall Memorial and the Stasi Museum. The legacy of Communist tyranny is literally underfoot, in the form of the double row of cobblestones that marks much of the path of the Berlin Wall across streets and sidewalks.
It also makes me personally angry as somebody who has spent a tiny amount of time in actual Communist countries–the Soviet Union in 1989, China five times in the last 30 years. I know what Communism looks like, I hate what it has done to people around the world, and I can recognize the difference between that grotesque ideology and the stuff of contemporary American political debates.
(The picture at the left is the teenage version of myself in the Kremlin; I did not get arrested for wearing that Amnesty International t-shirt but I’d like to think that I got some dirty looks.)
German history provides another useful parallel: Here, the Communist strategy after 1945 was to win one election and then make the others meaningless. That should be good cause for the architect of the Jan. 6 attempted coup to take a long look in the mirror before throwing around Communist comparisons–but we all know Trump didn’t get elected in 2016 for his contemplative nature.
And as I was writing this, the absurdity of the former president’s “Comrade Kamala” argument leveled up yet again Wednesday with the unsealing of a Department of Justice indictment alleging that Russian operatives arranged six-figure monthly payments to right-wing influencers who rank among Trump’s biggest supporters. Will those allegations stop them from parroting his new talking point about his opponent? I think we know the answer there.
These people exhuming McCarthy today are not serious people. None of them deserves your attention, much less your vote.
https://robpegoraro.com/2024/09/05/spare-me-your-phony-red-scare/
#Berlin #BerlinWall #Communism #CommunistParty #DonaldTrump #ElonMusk #GDR #KamalaHarris #Marxist #MarxistLeninism #MarxistLeninist #Russia #SovietUnion #Stasi #USSR