Weiterhin angefressen vom Dauercrash von #Lightworks unter #UbuntuStudio #Linux 24.04 gibt es eine Resthoffnung, dass meine alte #Radeon #rx480 #GPU schuld ist. Heute entdeckte ich eine alte #NvidiaQuadro in meiner Schublade. Ursprünglich eine High-End-Workstation-Grafiikarte, allerdings schon ziemlich alt.

Die Dell-Workstation, mit der diese Karte geliefert wurde, begibt sich allerdings displaybefreit in eine Boot-Endlosschleife, offenbar noch vor Erreichen des Bootloades… sobald ich diese Karte eingebaut habe.

Ich schieße also in der eBucht eine gebrauchte Nvidia 1070ti mit furchteinflößend aussehenden Lüftern.

Diese ganze PC-Bastelei fuckt mich hart ab. Vor 20 Jahren hätte ich Spaß dran gehabt, heute ist einfach so: Aaah funktionier doch einfach!

🧵 Turns out, after a journey of many hours with #Lightworks… (and hoped-for alternatives)

… they have introduced new video scopes based on #OpenCL which do not always work.

Since I just recently got to work AMD OpenCL on my #Linux box, these new scopes changed #LKWS behavior to constant crashing, yet it enabled to run #DavinciResolve at all.

The Lightworks #NLE people were smart enough to put a switch in the project workspace's menu to deactivate these “advanced scopes”… yet the switch forgets its setting and needs to be flicked on every start.

This is exactly underlining my criticism about Lightworks these days: They have good ideas, they try to tackle them, but they make things worse by not fully managing.

E.g., there's VST3 audio plugin support now which does work – but on export of the video, it introduces an ugly noise in the beginning of your exported clip. So it's perfect but still useless.

Now trying to remember what I was about to do half a day ago.

🧵 So, now that I #Resolve didn't work, #OpenShot was too stupid, #Kdenlive is lacking playback performance, I thought…

… well if that #rgbParade crashes that hole of bugs called #Lightworks I have been using for years, why not just… switch off that scope and use an external analyzer.

Attached this #Lilliput field monitor that can do rgbParade, and from there passing through to my Eizo.

Turns out: The HDMI output of that monitor is not compatible with the DVI input of my old Eizo monitors. No image.

So now that I have explored all ways of failing, which perhaps would be a therapist's description of being clinically manic, the only solution remaining is: Don't do it.

There's a little hope still that Lightworks will not go bankrupt but instead will manage to fix the heap of bugs they introduced lately. This still won't give them really working audio editing,m but still…

#VideoEditing / #NLE on #Linux…

🧵 #Lightworks fails me, #Blackmagic doesn't want me to try their #DaVincieResolve since it can't do h264 on #Linux (except you pay a lot of cash), #OpenShot is too stupid (can't do full screen monitor, and after 5 minutes of not finding out how to mute an audio track, I gave up on it)…

… now back at where it all started with my video editing on 2014 or so: #Kdenlive.

Now that looks familiar still. And it still can't do GPU acceleration. Oh well, it can, but the option is greyed-out even though I have libmovit8 installed.

So while Lightworks has learned to effectively play back even h265 on elderly machines, even without GPU decoding, Kdenlive already struggles playing back 4k h264 with flip and flop effect on that clip. (Lightworks uses OpenCL for FX, as would Resolve)

Actually after now 1,5hrs of trying to get a decent #NLE to run on Linux, after more than 10 years of doing video on Linux, I'm not at all in the mood for doing creative video work any more now.

🧵 20 min of 1-camera video shoot, already over 1hr trying to get a #NLE on #Linux to work.

#Lightworks current beta (I paid for the entire product range)… crashes on displaying RGB parade or vectorscope.

#DavinciResolve: Hard to install, free version does not read h264 video on Linux (only on Windows, Mac), “patch” to enabled Proversion testing without spending almost 400€ requires advanced knowledge of #Rust.

Now #OpenShot offers an #AppImage download, that by nature cannot work with #Pipewire audio. There is a #PPA for #Ubuntu users, though… https://launchpad.net/~openshot.developers/+archive/ubuntu/ppa

… turns out OpenShot cannot do fullscreen video preview. Just not possible. WTF.

Ultimately I must get #Resolve to run and learn to use it, it's an industry standard at least.

After all, this journey started with the desire to make a 3 minute video with the tool I already have and did pay for.

@zahntron From all #Linux video editors that I assessed, the best seems to be #DavinciResolve (proprietary) and #KDEnlive, and with a somewhat different focus #Blender.
Contender #Shotcut.
Also available #OpenShot #Lightworks (proprietary) #Flowblade #Olive #Avidemux #Pitivi

PLEASE UPDATE: My assessment is from September 2024, if one of the video editors has progressed substantially, please respond!

@system76 @jorge #Davinci #videoeditor #videoeditors #videocut #floss #opensource