DOJ Lawyer: RFK Jr.’s Authority Shall Not Suffer Any Checks & Balances From The Courts

I’ve spent a lot of digital ink detailing just how bad RFK Jr. has been in his post at HHS. Everything from his attempts to entirely remake vaccine policies in the country, to his neutered re…

Techdirt

'Constitutional Control over the Negative Deviation from the Legislative Purpose: A Study on Egyptian Constitutional Court Rulings and Qatari Legislation Models' - a new publication in the International Review of Law (IRL) on #ScienceOpen:

📘 https://www.scienceopen.com/document?vid=53d5678f-343d-4a92-a7de-de88e5c08cdf

#ConstitutionalLaw #LegislativeOmission #ComparativeConstitutionalism #JudicialOversight

Constitutional Control over the Negative Deviation from the Legislative Purpose: A Study on Egyptian Constitutional Court Rulings and Qatari Legislation Models <span class="so-article-trans-title" dir="auto"> Translated title: الرقابة الدستورية على الانحراف التشريعي الغائي السلبي – دراسة في أحكام القضاء الدستوري في مصر ونماذج من التشريع القطري </span>

<p xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" class="first" dir="auto" id="d19307930e39">This research is taken from a doctoral dissertation entitled “Constitutional control of the Purpose of Legislation: An Analytical Study between Egypt and Qatar.” It addresses the issue of constitutional control over the defect of negative teleological deviation, whether in the form of legislative omission or in the form of evasion of jurisdiction. The problem arises when legislation is issued neglecting some aspects whose omission would result in wasting the goals that the constitution requires to be achieved, or when the legislator relinquishes his jurisdiction to legislate to another authority, neglecting the constitutional goals of entrusting the regulation of this subject to him. In both cases, constitutional control over negative teleological deviation comes to address this. matter. The research reviewed many rulings of the constitutional judiciary in Egypt and then deduced the principles it reached in this regard. It also examined many models of Qatari legislation that are suspected of falling into negative teleological deviation. The study concluded with several results, the most important of which are: that the Supreme Court in Egypt did not reject censorship. Constitutionalism on the legislative omission, and the Supreme Constitutional Court has already exercised its jurisdiction to constitutionally monitor the negative teleological deviation in many of its rulings. The research showed examples in Qatari legislation that require intervention by the legislator to avoid neglect of constitutional goals. </p><p xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" class="first" dir="auto" id="d19307930e42">يهدف البحث إلى معالجة مسألة مهمّة تتعلق بالرقابة الدستورية على عيب الانحراف التشريعي الغائي السلبي، سواء أكان في صورة الإغفال التشريعي أم التسلب من الاختصاص. وتتجلى أهمية البحث في حداثة فكرة الرقابة الدستورية على الانحراف الغائي السلبي؛ إذ تثور المشكلة حينما يَصدر التشريع مُغفلًا بعض الجوانب التي يترتب على إغفالها إهدارٌ لغاياتٍ تطلّب الدستور تحقيقها، أو عندما يتنازل المشرع عن اختصاصه بالتشريع لسلطة أخرى، فتُهدر الغايات الدستورية من إسناد تنظيم هذا الموضوع إليه، وفي كلتا الصورتين تأتي الرقابة الدستورية على الانحراف الغائي السلبي لمعالجة هذه المسألة. اعتمد البحث المنهج الاستقرائي الاستنباطي التحليلي المقارن؛ فعرض للعديد من أحكام القضاء الدستوري في مصر ثم استنبط المبادئ التي انتهى إليها في هذا الشأن، كما تفحّص العديد من نماذج التشريع القطري التي يُشتبه بوقوعها في الانحراف الغائي السلبي، واستعان بالآراء الفقهية لوضع تعريفات واضحة لصور هذا العيب.  خلص البحث إلى أن المحكمة العليا في مصر لم ترفض الرقابة الدستورية على الإغفال التشريعي، وأنها باشرت بالفعل اختصاصها بالرقابة الدستورية على الانحراف الغائي السلبي في العديد من أحكامها، وبيّن البحث نماذج في التشريع القطري تستدعي تدخلًا من المشرع لتفادي ما شابها من تفريط بالغايات الدستورية. </p>

ScienceOpen
Elon Musk calls for impeachment of federal judge over ruling blocking DOGE's access to Treasury systems, sparking debate on executive power and judicial oversight
#YonhapInfomax #ElonMusk #FederalJudge #DOGE #TreasuryAccess #JudicialOversight #Economics #FinancialMarkets #Banking #Securities #Bonds #StockMarket
https://en.infomaxai.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=50197
Musk Calls for Federal Judge's Impeachment, Protests DOGE's Treasury Access Block Ruling

Elon Musk calls for impeachment of federal judge over ruling blocking DOGE's access to Treasury systems, sparking debate on executive power and judicial oversight

Yonhap Infomax
The best minute and a half from yesterday's judicial oversight committee hearing.
https://youtu.be/xHHHwPrANi8?si=TBVSZZ_r9KrbuRhW
#EricSwalwell #JimJordan #MerrickGarland #Congress #JudicialOversight
Swalwell displays 'Jordan subpoena evasion' clock at Garland hearing

YouTube
Sen. Whitehouse Asks Roberts To Do Something, Anything About Alito

In a Tuesday letter to Chief Justice John Roberts, Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI) accused Justice Samuel Alito of "obstructing a congressional investigation" and demanded that Roberts take some form…

TPM – Talking Points Memo
Be really afraid. If #DonaldTrump is elected president, America will become an authoritarian government who will rid the country if #JudicialOversight like Israel is attempting. #SaveDemocracy #VoteBlue #JoeBiden2024 https://l.smartnews.com/p-ruLCm/9DpdYg
Hundreds of thousands march in Israel against Netanyahu's judicial overhaul (NPR)

Trusted by over 40+ million worldwide readers, SmartNews provides the best news, stories and events across 200+ local news sites.

Oh Supreme Court of Israel,
You are ever so wise and loyal
Your judgements are fair and just
And can never be unjust
We honor your high justice and vow

#israel #supremecourt #judicialoversight #ode #poetry

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-66055040

Netanyahu drops key part of Israel judicial overhaul plans

The PM says he will no longer seek to give parliament the power to overturn Supreme Court rulings.

BBC News

'“I don’t know what the judges will rule in the end, but the general feeling — including among the lawyers — is that the judges are going to overrule [Deri’s] appointment. Even if our arguments were correct, they won’t value them because of what Levin did,” the source said, expressing frustration and anger that Levin had not consulted with Shas officials before making his announcement.'

I think that part of the problem the current governing coalition has is that they don't understand that courts generally don't base their decisions on petty considerations like these.

Judges aim to apply consistent principles, fairly. At least more than politicians whose principles seem to shift a little too often.

#Israel #IsraeliSupremeCourt #JudicialOversight

https://www.timesofisrael.com/deri-confidants-fear-court-will-nix-his-appointment-blame-levins-legal-bombshell/?utm_source=pocket_mylist

Deri confidants fear court will nix his appointment, blame Levin’s legal ‘bombshell’

Sources close to Shas leader accuse justice minister of antagonizing court by announcing far-reaching reforms to undercut their power on eve of crucial hearing