Apparently we're fighting about #Hashtagging on the Fediverse today.
Genuine question:
How can we determine fine line between "creating #Hashtag spam" and "using enough #hastags for people's filters"?
My POV:
I'm dyslexic & find that having important words/phrases #hashtagged makes it easier to read longer posts. I also like when there are a few fun or niche #tags on weird shit.
@EgyptianAphorist ...and, yet, here they are
#hashtagged by name...🤔
@laurailway @ThePlant I was being a bit faceous, but the important categories should be
#hashtagged in the very least, be it inline or at bottom of a toot, it matters not
@ThePlant #hashtags, if people #hashtagged all the #nouns (and some #verbs) in their #toots #everything #would #be #more #discoverable
and then you'd just follow the hashtags you like
Now obviously there are limitations to finding anything on mastodon if it's not #hashtagged but that still doesn't make things hidden unless the post is restricted.
On #hashtags there is the issue of people using but not following or looking at them and that is besides the point of most people not using them for content others would like to discover here.
Post from a #Calckey node about #fediverse response to #earthquakes (& by extension, other #NaturalDisasters).
Short version: #Mastodon doesn't do very well; Calckey does much better, because the user is able to quickly surface non-#hashtagged conversations.
Great illustrations of why #FediverseSearch is good, actually, & why #hashtags aren't a substitute for #search.
#MissedQuoteBoost #MastodonSearch
https://calckey.social/notes/9fb2lj1yam

@maegul
Ok, nice little social media experiment, how does the fediverse fare during an earthquake?
A midnight earthquake just hit my home city, which basically never gets earthquakes. Probably no damage at all from this one, but we all definitely felt it, which is unusual for us! (Prob ~4 on Richter scale)
Where did I go first to check if others felt it? NGL, the place I went last time there was a tremor … Twitter. And to be fair, on the top of my feed were posts from people I follow (who aren’t here) that live in my home city, tweeting about it, including links to official reports. This was very nice, as this time I was scared and thought my apartment building might be in trouble.
I quickly check #mastodon and #calckey. Nothing in timelines. Not surprising, I don’t really follow anyone or many that live in the same city as me.
Searching, mastodon’s hashtag search does ok, and surfaces a bot or two that also confirm the quake (@[email protected]). But not many people, I’m not really finding a conversation. Also searching for something by a hashtag you don’t know exists takes a few steps. This is on an instance with ~50k users.
#Calckey’s full text search though (on calckey.social)?
Quicker. Just typed earthquake without worrying about hashtags.
And better results. More people were brought up, which is kinda what you’re after from social media during an event … reassurance. It was also surprising, as calckey has only ~2k users and therefore smaller visibility of the fediverse, but still gave me more connectivity just through search than my bigger mastodon instance.
Which is really an interesting demonstration of how hashtags can be problematic. Plenty of people were reaching out, asking “anyone feel that earthquake?”, they just forgot or didn’t think to use a hashtag, and so couldn’t find me through mastodon. And why would you in a (slightly) nervous situation like that. “Hmmm, is this the best hashtag, do you think people will search for it … I should probably check if it exists first?” … is not a thought goes through your mind.
I basically never visit Twitter since I left, but this was a nostalgic little episode. It was nice to see the fediverse wasn’t really behind big social. Though the lack of discovery facilities on mastodon really did show themselves here.
Calckey Social@johnhobbs There are a few key things that help on mastodon:
(1) #HASHTAGS - Text search is disabled on this platform, which means the only searchable text is text that is #hashtagged. Without hashtags, your post will only be found by people that follow you and happen to be online when you post it.