I'm in a reflective mood today, with the start of Ramadan, and so when I saw this great post by my friend Mark Hertling, DBA, I reacted to it JOINTLY as a believer and a (also retired) GO-level leader. Because God designed this dunya--this worldly life--as a trial (and He knows what we do not!), we get the tests THAT WE NEED, not necessarily (to adapt some Rumsfeld!) the tests we might WANT to have!
So perhaps the takeaway here is that the test we NEED in this moment, as a professional class, is--while not the one the #Donjjal might be thinking of--EXACTLY this: will we honor our collective Oath, "to support and defend the Constitution of the United States against ALL enemies, foreign AND DOMESTIC" (emphasis added)...or will we "go along to get along," using our (in this case, competing) duty to carry out, to the best of our ability, the policies of whoever 'We, the People' elected over us as a tattered and increasingly flimsy excuse NOT TO support and defend the Constitution against these open enemies--even as they planfully dismantle the liberties it guarantees and demolish it around us, and a majority of the American people signal their increasing rage & anxiety against their betrayal?
Should democracy--and our Flag and General Officer Corps--survive this test, in sha' Allah, I would love to one day return to the U.S. Naval War College to again lead (or perhaps CO-lead with my wife, who is the actual ethics scholar and author of a framework for ethics not merely as moral philosophizing, but as INTENTIONAL DECISION MAKING) the professional ethics program for a few years--for which a thoughtful & frank contention with how we must balance these obligations when they ARE in opposition must surely be the organizing theme for a few years.
https://www.thebulwark.com/p/americas-generals-shouldnt-face-political-loyalty-tests-hegseth-promotion-list-butler-milley-army