#Palestine / "Netanyahu Should Only Be Pardoned if He Leaves Political Life" ... former Israeli supreme court chief's pardon stance contradicts decades of whitewashing international law violations

Former Israeli Supreme Court President Aharon Barak argues against pardoning #Netanyahu before conviction, because he's concerned about political motivations and proper legal procedures.

https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/2025-06-30/ty-article-opinion/.premium/netanyahu-should-only-be-pardoned-if-he-leaves-political-life/00000197-c209-d2f9-a3f7-c2df0b320000 or https://archive.ph/3uUXZ

Barak's 28-year judicial record shows systematic whitewashing of Israeli violations of international law. His court maintained 100% approval rates for Palestinian administrative detention, upheld house demolitions as collective punishment, authorized targeted killings, and deliberately rejected #ICJ rulings on the separation wall.

In fact, legal analysts note Barak's court provided "cloak of legality" for settlement expansion while systematically ignoring international law and Palestinian rights.

References:

The myth of Israel's liberal supreme court exposed https://merip.org/2012/02/the-myth-of-israels-liberal-supreme-court-exposed/

Aharon Barak and Israel's legal illegality https://insightbulletin.org/aharon-barak-and-israels-legal-illegality/

Israel judge Aharon Barak at ICJ legitimised occupation https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/israel-judge-aharon-barak-icj-legitimised-occupation

@israel
@palestine
#AharonBarak #Netanyahu #IsraeliSupremeCourt #InternationalLaw #Gaza #WestBank #ICJ

Quoting Yinon Achiman (ינון אחימן, head of the Efrat Council, an illegal settlement in the occupied West Bank):

"As someone who headed the council for 15 years, I can say that the settlement enterprise owes a great deal to the Supreme Court and to Aharon Barak. The protection they provided — sometimes also through non-intervention — allowed the settlement enterprise to expand and develop."

Reminder: the Israeli government appointed Barak as an ad hoc judge to serve on the International Court of Justice case South Africa v. Israel, brought against Israel by South Africa on charges of genocide.

@israel
@palestine
#IsraelOccupation
#IsraelWarCrimes
#AharonBarak
#OatmealQuotes

This leapt out to me this morning. It's significant, but I'm not sure why.
----
#JERUSALEM (Reuters) - #AharonBarak, a former president of #Israel's #SupremeCourt, has resigned from his role as ad hoc judge on an #InternationalCourtOfJustice panel weighing a #genocide
allegation filed over the country's war in #Gaza, officials said on Wednesday. #TheHague

Israel's Barak quits ICJ panel, citing personal reasons
https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/world/israel-s-barak-quits-icj-panel-citing-personal-reasons/ar-BB1nHoh8?ocid=emmx-mmx-feeds&PC=EMMX01

MSN

The ICJ just took the Holocaust monopoly away from Israel – @mondoweiss
https://mondoweiss.net/2024/01/the-icj-just-took-the-holocaust-monopoly-away-from-israel/ (29 Jan 2024)

'Unsurprisingly, the Israeli judge ad hoc Aharon Barak desperately tried to save the monopoly on being victims forever.'

Jonathan Ofir on the Israelian judge Aharon Baraks dissenting opinion on the ICJ Order.

#ICJ #Israel #Gaza #AharonBarak #Holocaust

The ICJ just took the Holocaust monopoly away from Israel

The International Court of Justice’s genocide ruling shows Israel is no longer viewed as the eternal victim, and the Holocaust no longer shields it from scrutiny for the most grave crimes against humanity.

Mondoweiss

La terza delle misure provvisorie emesse dal tribunale venerdì, firmata dall'ex presidente della Corte Suprema israeliana #AharonBarak, giudice ad hoc di Israele nel caso, ordina a Israele di adottare tutte le misure in suo potere per prevenire e punire l'incitamento diretto e pubblico al genocidio dei palestinesi nella Striscia di #Gaza.

Sembra che Israele debba ora indagare, ed eventualmente punire, il suo Presidente e i due più importanti Ministri del governo, che avrebbero dovuto essere convocati dalla polizia già domenica mattina.

Israele non lo farà, ovviamente, ma è impossibile ignorare i sospetti sollevati dal tribunale sul cuore stesso di Israele. ⬇️3

"The rulings, all passed by either 16-1 or 15-2 – even the appointed Israeli judge, Aharon Barak, sided twice with the majority – are devastating for Israel, though a final judgment is still a long way off. Meanwhile, those governments which argued that South Africa’s case was empty and illegitimate now need to dig themselves out of the hole of their own creation."

#gaza #israel #ICJ #genocide #SouthAfrica #Palestine #AharonBarak #TheHague #UK #US #Deutschland

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/jan/26/israel-gaza-icj-genocide-ruling-the-hague

This momentous ICJ ruling may be brushed aside by Israel - but the US and UK can’t afford to ignore it

If this judgment is not heeded, how can Putin ever be held to account? Justice with double standards is no justice at all, says author Steve Crawshaw

The Guardian

“Barak’s record as a former chief justice of Israel’s Supreme Court is not liberal in any convincing way when one considers his rulings regarding #Palestinians, whether Israeli citizens or residents in the #OccupiedTerritories." - #NimerSultany

#AharonBarak: #Israel's judge at the #ICJ who 'legitimised occupation'

https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/israel-judge-aharon-barak-icj-legitimised-occupation

#genocide #Gaza #Palestine #GazaGenocide #oPt #InternationalCourtOfJustice #OccupiedPalestinianTerritories #GenocideConvention #UNGenocideConvention

Aharon Barak: Israel's judge at the ICJ who 'legitimised occupation'

Israeli pick for genocide case at The Hague championed for liberal credentials, but analysts say he paved the way for abuses against Palestinians

Middle East Eye

Aharon Barak, Israel’s former Supreme Court chief justice, will serve as a judge at the International Court of Justice on a panel to hear South Africa’s genocide case against Israel.

Barak, 87, is an influential Israeli jurist with international renown and a Holocaust survivor. He will be among the judges deciding whether to issue an interim order demanding Israel halt its war. Such orders are legally binding – but not always enforceable.

@palestine
#Israel
#ICJ
#AharonBarak

Under the #ICJ’s rules a state that does not have a judge of its nationality already on the bench can choose an ad hoc judge to sit in their case. #TheHague

#Israel names former supreme court president #AharonBarak to ICJ panel ahead of #SouthAfrica's #genocide case hearing
https://www.theguardian.com/world/live/2024/jan/07/middle-east-crisis-live-israel-west-bank-jenin-palestinian-ministry-latest-updates?page=with:block-659ac87d8f08640ae963b92e#block-659ac87d8f08640ae963b92e

Back toot: https://noc.social/@Norobiik/111696933912393850

Middle East crisis live: Israel says it has completed mission to destroy Hamas infrastructure in northern Gaza

Offensive will now shift to southern Gaza, as Netanyahu insists war is not over

the Guardian